B15 · Worked examples
These questions work with a given sample data set. We did not measure it. You make a table, compare the measured values with the table predictions, find a percent difference, explain a gap and judge the design. The percent difference, also called percent error, is (predicted − measured) ÷ predicted × 100. The unit V is the volt.
Open the B15 lesson · B15 slide notes
Worked question types
Each example shows every step, why you do it, and the idea behind it.
Question typePut the given results in a data table
Use this when: The question gives predicted and measured values and asks you to organize them in a table, or to say what a good table includes.
Example. This is a given sample set, not measured by us. Each metal is joined to a copper half-cell, all 1.0 mol/L. Cd/Cu: predicted 0.74 V, measured 0.69 V. Co/Cu: predicted 0.62 V, measured 0.58 V. Pb/Cu: predicted 0.47 V, measured 0.43 V. Ag/Cu: predicted 0.46 V, measured 0.40 V. Organize the evidence in a table. Say which column holds observations and which holds predictions.
- Write a title.
Use Method: how to analyze and explain results. A title says what the table shows.
Predicted and measured cell voltages for four metals joined to copper (given sample set)
- Choose the columns and put the units in the headings.
Put prediction and measurement side by side so they are easy to compare.
Cell | Predicted voltage (V) | Measured voltage (V) | Difference (V)
- Fill in the rows.
Each row is one cell.
Cd/Cu: 0.74, 0.69 Co/Cu: 0.62, 0.58 Pb/Cu: 0.47, 0.43 Ag/Cu: 0.46, 0.40
- Fill in the difference column.
The difference is the predicted value minus the measured value.
Cd/Cu: 0.05 Co/Cu: 0.04 Pb/Cu: 0.04 Ag/Cu: 0.06
- Add a note of the conditions.
The reader needs to know what was kept the same.
All solutions 1.0 mol/L. Data supplied, not measured by us
- Label the columns by their source.
Measured values came from a voltmeter, so they are observations. Predicted values were calculated from the reduction table.
measured = observations. predicted = from the table
Why this works. A table puts the evidence in one place so a reader can compare. The units in the headings stop confusion. Labelling the source of each column keeps observations and predictions apart.
Check your answer. The table has a title, units in every heading, the conditions, and one row per cell. Count four rows.
Common mistake. Mixing predicted and measured numbers in one column. Each column must come from one source.
Answer: Table with the title, units (V), the four rows, a difference column and a note of 1.0 mol/L. Measured values are observations
Question typeCompare measured values with predictions
Use this when: The question gives predicted and measured values and asks for the differences, the pattern, the order and whether the data support the prediction.
Example. Use the given sample set. Cd/Cu: predicted 0.74 V, measured 0.69 V. Co/Cu: predicted 0.62 V, measured 0.58 V. Pb/Cu: predicted 0.47 V, measured 0.43 V. Ag/Cu: predicted 0.46 V, measured 0.40 V. Find the difference for each cell. Describe the pattern in direction and size. Compare the order. Do the data support the prediction?
- Subtract for each cell.
The difference is the predicted voltage minus the measured voltage.
Cd/Cu: 0.74 − 0.69 = 0.05 V Co/Cu: 0.62 − 0.58 = 0.04 V Pb/Cu: 0.47 − 0.43 = 0.04 V Ag/Cu: 0.46 − 0.40 = 0.06 V
- Describe the direction.
A positive difference means the measured value is lower than the prediction. All four are positive.
every measured voltage is lower than predicted
- Describe the size.
Give the unit and the range.
the gaps are between 0.04 V and 0.06 V
- Compare the order.
Rank the cells from highest to lowest voltage for each column.
predicted: Cd/Cu, Co/Cu, Pb/Cu, Ag/Cu. measured: Cd/Cu, Co/Cu, Pb/Cu, Ag/Cu. the order matches
- Write the judgement.
Evidence rarely proves an idea. Say that the data support it, and say why.
The data support the prediction, in order and in size, with a small gap that is always in the same direction
Why this works. A prediction is tested by comparing it with an observation. Order tells you if the table ranks the metals correctly. Size tells you how close the values are. A gap in one direction for every cell points to something that affects all the cells.
Check your answer. Your description gives a direction (lower), a size with the unit (0.04 V to 0.06 V) and a comparison of the order.
Common mistake. Saying the numbers are close without a size or unit. State how much and which way.
Answer: Differences: Cd/Cu 0.05 V, Co/Cu 0.04 V, Pb/Cu 0.04 V, Ag/Cu 0.06 V. All measured values are lower. The order matches. The data support the prediction
Question typeFind a percent difference and judge the size of a gap
Use this when: The question gives a predicted and a measured value and asks how big the gap is compared with the prediction, as a percent.
Example. These are given results. Cell A is an iron and silver cell: predicted 1.25 V, measured 1.14 V. Cell B is a cadmium and copper cell: predicted 0.74 V, measured 0.69 V. Find the percent difference for each cell. Which cell agrees more closely with the table?
- Write the formula.
Percent difference compares the gap with the predicted value.
percent difference = (predicted − measured) ÷ predicted × 100
- Find the difference for cell A.
Subtract. The answer has two decimal places.
1.25 − 1.14 = 0.11 V
- Divide and multiply for cell A.
Keep one extra digit in the middle value. The difference 0.11 has two significant digits, so the final answer has two.
0.11 ÷ 1.25 × 100 = 8.80 → 8.8 %
- Find the difference for cell B.
The difference 0.05 has one significant digit.
0.74 − 0.69 = 0.05 V
- Divide and multiply for cell B.
Keep one extra digit in the middle value. The final answer has one significant digit.
0.05 ÷ 0.74 × 100 = 6.8 → 7 %
- Compare.
The smaller percent difference is the closer agreement.
cell B (7 %) is closer than cell A (8.8 %)
Why this works. A gap of 0.05 V matters more for a small voltage than for a large one. The percent difference divides by the prediction, so it shows the gap in proportion. The number of significant digits comes from the subtraction.
Check your answer. Both percents are small, under 10 %. A value near 100 % would mean the measurement and the prediction disagree badly.
Common mistake. Dividing by the measured value, or forgetting to multiply by 100. Divide by the predicted value.
Answer: Cell A: 8.8 %. Cell B: 7 %. Cell B agrees more closely
Question typeExplain a gap with possible causes and test one
Use this when: The question gives a gap between prediction and measurement, and asks for a possible cause, a test for it, or a judgement of a student’s explanation.
Example. In the given cadmium and copper result, the measured voltage was 0.69 V and the predicted voltage was 0.74 V. A student writes: “Oxide on the strips caused the gap.” To test this, the strips are sanded and measured again. The new reading is 0.72 V. Judge the student’s claim. Give one other possible cause.
- Find the gap before the test.
Subtract the measured value from the predicted value.
0.74 − 0.69 = 0.05 V
- Find the gap after the test.
Use the new reading.
0.74 − 0.72 = 0.02 V
- Compare the gaps.
The voltage moved toward the prediction. Removing the oxide changed one thing, so the oxide is part of the cause.
the gap fell from 0.05 V to 0.02 V
- Say what is not shown.
A gap of 0.02 V is still left. So the oxide was not the whole cause, and “caused the gap” says too much.
rewrite: oxide is a possible part of the cause
- Give another possible cause.
Other causes were not tested, so they stay possible, not proven. The table values assume 25.00 °C and 1.0 mol/L.
for example: the salt bridge adds resistance, or the room temperature is not 25.00 °C
Why this works. A possible cause becomes evidence only when you change one thing and measure again. Even then, the result may only show a part of the cause. Do not claim a cause that you did not test.
Check your answer. The test moved the voltage by 0.03 V toward the prediction, which is most but not all of the original gap.
Common mistake. Writing that a cause is proven because the numbers moved in the right direction. A partial change shows a partial cause.
Answer: The test supports oxide as part of the cause, but not all of it. A gap of 0.02 V remains. Another possible cause: salt bridge resistance or temperature
Question typeSeparate observations from inferences and identify the products
Use this when: The question lists what was seen in a cell and asks which statements are observations, which are inferences, and what the products are.
Example. An iron strip is placed in blue Cu²⁺ solution. Statements: S1 A reddish-brown coating forms on the strip. S2 The blue colour fades. S3 Fe is oxidized to Fe²⁺. S4 The strip loses mass. S5 Cu²⁺ gained electrons. Sort the statements into observations and inferences. Write the cell reaction.
- Ask if you could see or measure it.
An observation is what you see or measure. An inference is a conclusion drawn from observations.
seen or measured, or reasoned
- Sort S1, S2 and S4.
You can see the coating and the colour fade. You can measure the mass.
S1, S2 and S4 are observations
- Sort S3 and S5.
Electrons and ions changing charge cannot be seen. They are reasoned from the observations.
S3 and S5 are inferences
- Link each inference to its evidence.
The coating supports Cu²⁺ reduced to Cu. The mass loss supports Fe oxidized to Fe²⁺.
coating → Cu forms. mass loss → Fe²⁺ forms
- Write the cell reaction.
Iron gives two electrons. One Cu²⁺ takes two.
Fe + Cu²⁺ → Fe²⁺ + Cu
Why this works. The products are inferred from what you observe. Fe²⁺ is not seen directly, so it is an inference. A test can make an inference stronger, but you must always write which one you have.
Check your answer. Atoms and charge match in the reaction: Fe 1, Cu 1, and +2 on each side.
Common mistake. Listing “Fe²⁺ forms” as an observation. You did not see it, so it is an inference.
Answer: Observations: S1, S2, S4. Inferences: S3, S5. Reaction: Fe + Cu²⁺ → Fe²⁺ + Cu
Question typeWrite a conclusion with a claim, evidence and a possible explanation
Use this when: The question gives a result and asks for a conclusion about whether it supports the prediction.
Example. This result is supplied, not measured by us. A cobalt and copper cell has predicted voltage 0.62 V and measured voltage 0.57 V. The cobalt strip lost mass and the copper strip gained a coating. Write a conclusion with a claim, evidence and a possible explanation for the gap.
- Decide the claim.
Compare the two voltages. Then check that the strip changes fit a cobalt anode and a copper cathode.
The Co and Cu cell agrees with the table prediction
- Give the numerical evidence.
Quote the numbers with units and the gap.
measured 0.57 V, predicted 0.62 V, so the gap is 0.05 V
- Give the observed evidence.
Quote what was seen.
the cobalt strip lost mass and the copper strip gained a coating
- Write the reaction.
Cobalt is oxidized and Cu²⁺ is reduced. Both take or give two electrons.
Co + Cu²⁺ → Co²⁺ + Cu
- Give a possible explanation.
Name causes that could lower the voltage. Do not say they are proven, because they were not tested.
salt bridge resistance or oxide on the strips could lower the voltage
Why this works. A full conclusion has a claim, the evidence for it, and an explanation. The claim answers the question. The evidence is the numbers and observations. The explanation says how the cause could produce the result.
Check your answer. Your claim agrees with the evidence: the measured 0.57 V is 0.05 V below 0.62 V.
Common mistake. Giving the explanation as a fact. Write “could lower” and not “lowered”.
Answer: Claim: the cell agrees with the table. Evidence: 0.57 V against 0.62 V and the strip changes. Co + Cu²⁺ → Co²⁺ + Cu. Possible cause: salt bridge resistance or oxide
Question typeName a limitation with an improvement and use repeated trials
Use this when: The question describes how data were collected and asks for a limitation, a matching improvement, or an average of repeated trials.
Example. A design used one trial for each cell. In a given repeat of the cobalt and copper cell, three trials gave 0.56 V, 0.59 V and 0.57 V. The predicted voltage is 0.62 V. Name a limitation and an improvement. Find the mean of the three trials. Find the percent difference from the prediction.
- Name the limitation.
A limitation is a weakness in how the data were collected. One trial does not show how much a measurement varies.
only one trial for each cell
- Name the matching improvement.
Every limitation needs an improvement that fixes it.
repeat three trials and average them. Clean the strips before each trial
- Find the mean.
Add the trials and divide by 3. Keep one extra digit.
(0.56 + 0.59 + 0.57) ÷ 3 = 0.573 V → 0.57 V
- Find the range.
The range is the largest minus the smallest. It shows how much the trials vary.
0.59 − 0.56 = 0.03 V
- Find the percent difference.
Use the mean as the measured value. The difference 0.05 has one significant digit.
(0.62 − 0.57) ÷ 0.62 × 100 = 8.1 → 8 %
Why this works. An average of repeated trials is more reliable than one value, because the random variation partly cancels. The range tells you how much to trust the mean.
Check your answer. The mean 0.57 V sits between the smallest and largest trials, 0.56 V and 0.59 V.
Common mistake. Naming a limitation with no improvement. Each limitation needs a fix that matches it.
Answer: Limitation: one trial. Improvement: repeat three trials and average. Mean = 0.57 V. Percent difference = 8 %
Question typeEvaluate a battery design with the evidence
Use this when: The question describes a battery built from cells in a row and asks if the design is good, using voltage and other evidence.
Example. A team builds a battery of 4 iron and copper cells in a row. This is a given result. Each cell measured 0.76 V. The table predicts 0.79 V per cell. The device needs at least 3.0 V. Find the battery voltage and the percent difference from the prediction. Judge the design. Name one disposal step.
- Find the battery voltage.
Cells in a row add. Multiply one cell by the number of cells.
4 × 0.76 V = 3.04 V
- Find the predicted voltage.
Use the table value for one cell.
4 × 0.79 V = 3.16 V
- Find the percent difference.
The difference is 0.12 V, so the answer has two significant digits.
(3.16 − 3.04) ÷ 3.16 × 100 = 3.80 → 3.8 %
- Compare with the need.
The battery must give at least the voltage the device needs.
3.04 V − 3.0 V = 0.04 V of margin
- Judge the design.
The margin is small, and the voltage falls as the reactants are used. Voltage is only one piece of evidence.
the design may fail soon. Test the voltage over time, and compare mass, cost, lifetime and leaks
- Name a disposal step.
Used batteries contain metals that can harm soil and water.
collect used batteries for recycling, not for the garbage
Why this works. A battery is judged on more than voltage. A small margin above the need, a falling voltage, and the risk of leaks all count. Recycling recovers metals, but it also takes energy, so there are issues on both sides.
Check your answer. The measured battery voltage of 3.04 V is below the predicted 3.16 V and above the 3.0 V need.
Common mistake. Judging the battery only by whether the voltage passes the need. The margin and the evidence about time matter too.
Answer: Battery voltage = 3.04 V. Percent difference = 3.8 %. The margin is only 0.04 V, so test over time. Recycle used batteries
Question typePlan a fair short presentation about a fuel cell
Use this when: The question gives a draft claim about a technology and asks what a fair presentation must include.
Example. A draft slide says: “The hydrogen fuel cell is perfect.” The given half-reactions are H₂ → 2H⁺ + 2e⁻ and O₂ + 4H⁺ + 4e⁻ → 2H₂O. Table values: E°(O₂/H₂O) = +1.23 V and E°(H⁺/H₂) = 0.00 V. List what a fair presentation includes. Write the overall reaction and E°cell.
- State the purpose.
Say what the cell is for and why it matters.
to make electricity from hydrogen and oxygen that are given all the time
- Give the reactions.
Match the electrons, add the halves and cancel.
2H₂ + O₂ → 2H₂O
- Give the voltage.
E°cell is the cathode value minus the anode value. Do not multiply by the coefficients.
E°cell = +1.23 V − (0.00 V) = +1.23 V
- Give the benefits.
The only product at the cell is water.
benefit: water is the only product at the cell
- Give the limits.
The hydrogen must be made, stored and moved. Those steps use energy.
limit: how the hydrogen is made and stored
- Say where the evidence comes from.
A fair presentation names its sources so a reader can judge them.
name the source of each fact
Why this works. A fair presentation tells both sides. It states what the technology does well, what its limits are, and where the evidence comes from. The word “perfect” claims more than any evidence can support.
Check your answer. The presentation has a purpose, reactions, a voltage, a benefit, a limit and a source.
Common mistake. Listing only the benefits. A fair presentation also states the limits.
Answer: Include: purpose, half-reactions, benefits, limits, sources. 2H₂ + O₂ → 2H₂O. E°cell = +1.23 V
Diploma-style questions
Try each question first. Then open the worked solution.
Numerical response · outcome 30-B1.3sA given result gives a predicted voltage of 0.74 V and a measured voltage of 0.62 V. Find the percent difference. Record your answer as a whole number of percent. Enter the digits.
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
- Write the formula.
Percent difference = (predicted − measured) ÷ predicted × 100. The given value is the one the result gives.
- Subtract.
The difference has two significant digits.
0.74 − 0.62 = 0.12 V
- Divide and multiply.
Keep one extra digit in the middle value.
0.12 ÷ 0.74 × 100 = 16.2 → 16 %
- Enter the digits.
The value is 16 %, so enter 1 and 6.
record 1 6
Answer: 16 %. Record 1 6.
Multiple choice · outcome 30-B1.4sA zinc strip is placed in a blue Cu²⁺ solution. A reddish-brown solid forms on the strip and the blue colour fades. Which statement is an inference?
- A. A reddish-brown solid forms on the strip.
- B. The blue colour of the solution fades.
- C. Zinc gives electrons to Cu²⁺.
- D. The strip is covered with a solid.
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
- Sort the statements.
An observation is seen or measured. An inference is reasoned from it.
A and B are seen. C is reasoned. D is seen
- Choose C.
Electrons moving from zinc to Cu²⁺ cannot be seen.
answer C
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A. You can see the solid. This is an observation.
- B. You can see the colour fade. This is an observation.
- C. Correct. Electron transfer cannot be seen. It is reasoned from the coating and the fading colour.
- D. You can see the cover on the strip. This is an observation.
Answer: C
Multiple choice · outcome 30-B2.3sA cell was tested once, and the measured voltage was lower than predicted. Which change is the best improvement to the limitation of one trial?
- A. Use a 2.0 mol/L solution in the copper half-cell.
- B. Repeat the trial three times and average the voltages.
- C. Remove the salt bridge so there is less resistance.
- D. Use a larger voltmeter and one trial.
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
- Name the limitation.
One trial does not show how much a measurement varies.
- Match a fix to it.
Repeating the trial and averaging shows the variation and gives a more reliable value.
B
- Reject the others.
A, C and D change the conditions or remove a part, so they do not fix the limitation.
answer B
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A. The table values are for 1.0 mol/L. A different concentration changes the conditions and does not show the variation.
- B. Correct. Repeated trials show how much the voltage varies, and the average is more reliable than one value.
- C. Without the salt bridge, the circuit is not complete and the current stops.
- D. It is still one trial. A single reading cannot show how much the measurement varies.
Answer: B
Numerical response · outcome 30-B2.4sA battery has 5 cells in a row. This is a given result. Each cell measured 0.57 V. Find the battery voltage. Record your answer as a.bc V. Enter the digits a, b and c.
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
- Multiply.
Cells in a row add their voltages.
5 × 0.57 V = 2.85 V
- Enter the digits.
The value is 2.85, so a = 2, b = 8 and c = 5.
record 2 8 5
Answer: 2.85 V. Record 2 8 5.