B14 · Worked examples
These questions plan a test of the reduction table with real cells, before any measurement. You name the variables, label a design, predict with table values, and plan safe handling and a battery. E°cell is the cell voltage under standard conditions. These are 1.0 mol/L (moles per litre) solutions, 25.00 °C (degrees Celsius, which is 298.15 K, kelvin) and 101.325 kPa (kilopascals). The unit V is the volt.
Open the B14 lesson · B14 slide notes
Worked question types
Each example shows every step, why you do it, and the idea behind it.
Question typeName the question, the variables and the controls
Use this when: The question describes a planned test and asks for the independent variable, the dependent variable, the controlled variables, or what is wrong with a plan.
Example. A student joins each of the metals Zn, Fe, Ni and Pb to a silver half-cell. The silver half-cell is an Ag strip in 1.0 mol/L silver nitrate. Each metal sits in 1.0 mol/L of its own ions. A salt bridge joins each pair and a voltmeter reads the voltage. Write a testable question. Name the independent variable, the dependent variable and three controlled variables. The student uses 0.5 mol/L for the Fe half-cell. Explain why that breaks the test.
- Write the question.
Use Method: how to plan and predict an investigation. A testable question links one thing you change to one thing you measure.
How does the metal in one half-cell change the cell voltage?
- Name the independent variable.
The independent variable is the one you choose to change.
the metal (Zn, Fe, Ni or Pb)
- Name the dependent variable.
The dependent variable is the one you measure. It depends on what you changed.
the voltage on the voltmeter
- Name controlled variables.
A controlled variable is kept the same in every trial. The table values are for 1.0 mol/L at standard conditions, so concentration is a control.
concentration 1.0 mol/L, temperature, electrode size, salt bridge, the silver half-cell
- Count the trials.
Each metal is one trial.
4 metals = 4 cells
- Judge the 0.5 mol/L cell.
Two things now differ for that cell: the metal and the concentration. A voltage change could come from either.
the test is no longer fair, and the table cannot be compared
Why this works. A fair test changes one thing at a time. The controls let you say that a change in voltage came from the metal. The table values are given for 1.0 mol/L solutions, so that concentration also lets you compare with the table.
Check your answer. List the things in the setup that do not change. If the list is short, a hidden variable may be missing.
Common mistake. Naming the voltage as the independent variable. The voltage is what you read, so it is the dependent variable.
Answer: Independent: the metal. Dependent: the voltage. Controlled: concentration, temperature, electrode size, salt bridge. The 0.5 mol/L cell changes two things at once
Question typeList and label the parts of a cell design
Use this when: The question asks for a labelled diagram or a list of the parts of a design, with the anode, the cathode and the electron flow.
Example. Design a cell that joins a tin half-cell to a copper half-cell, both 1.0 mol/L. Table values: E°(Sn²⁺/Sn) = −0.14 V and E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V. List every part that the labelled diagram must show. Label the anode, the cathode and the direction of electron flow. Predict E°cell.
- Draw the two half-cells.
Each half-cell is a metal strip in a solution of its own ions. Write the concentration on each solution.
Sn(s) in 1.0 mol/L Sn²⁺(aq). Cu(s) in 1.0 mol/L Cu²⁺(aq)
- Join the solutions.
A salt bridge lets ions move so charge stays balanced and the circuit is complete.
salt bridge between the two solutions
- Add the outside circuit.
Wires connect the two strips through a voltmeter. The voltmeter reads the cell voltage.
wires and a voltmeter
- Predict before you label.
The lower table value is oxidized at the anode. The higher value is reduced at the cathode.
−0.14 V is lower than +0.34 V: tin is the anode, copper is the cathode
- Label the electron flow.
Electrons leave the anode and travel through the wire to the cathode.
arrow in the wire from Sn to Cu
- Predict the voltage.
E°cell is the cathode value minus the anode value.
E°cell = +0.34 V − (−0.14 V) = +0.48 V
Why this works. The labels come from the table, so the diagram shows what you expect to happen. The salt bridge is not optional. Without it, charge builds up in each half-cell and the current stops.
Check your answer. The diagram has two strips, two solutions with concentrations, a salt bridge, wires and a voltmeter. Count them.
Common mistake. Labelling the anode before predicting it. Compare the two table values first, then label.
Answer: Parts: two half-cells with concentrations, salt bridge, wires, voltmeter. Tin is the anode and copper is the cathode. Electrons flow from Sn to Cu. E°cell = +0.48 V
Question typePredict the anode, the cell reaction and E°cell before measuring
Use this when: The question gives two table values and asks for the anode, the cell reaction and the predicted voltage.
Example. Predict the cell made from an iron half-cell and a silver half-cell, both 1.0 mol/L. Table values: E°(Fe²⁺/Fe) = −0.45 V and E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V. Name the anode. Write the cell reaction. Find E°cell.
- Find the anode.
The lower table value is oxidized at the anode.
−0.45 V is lower than +0.80 V: iron is the anode, silver is the cathode
- Write the two halves.
The anode half runs backward from the table. The cathode half runs as printed.
Fe → Fe²⁺ + 2e⁻ Ag⁺ + e⁻ → Ag
- Match the electrons.
The iron half has 2e⁻ and the silver half has 1e⁻. The smallest number both go into is 2.
2 and 1 → 2
- Multiply each half.
Multiply every term of the iron half by 1 and every term of the silver half by 2.
iron × 1: Fe → Fe²⁺ + 2e⁻ | silver × 2: 2Ag⁺ + 2e⁻ → 2Ag
- Add the halves. Write every term before you cancel.
List all the left terms and all the right terms.
Fe + 2Ag⁺ + 2e⁻ → Fe²⁺ + 2e⁻ + 2Ag
- Cancel identical terms on opposite sides.
Electrons cancel. Cancel the same species that appear on both sides, such as H⁺ or H₂O, and keep what is left over.
cancelled: e⁻ → Fe + 2Ag⁺ → Fe²⁺ + 2Ag
- Check atoms and charge.
Both must match on the two sides.
charge: +2 = +2 ✓ atoms: Fe 1, Ag 2 ✓
- Subtract.
E°cell is the cathode value minus the anode value. Do not double +0.80 V.
E°cell = +0.80 V − (−0.45 V) = +1.25 V
Why this works. Each silver ion takes one electron, but each iron atom gives two. So the silver half is doubled to match. The table value is energy for each coulomb of charge, so doubling the half-reaction does not change it.
Check your answer. The charge is +2 on each side of the reaction. +1.25 V is a positive voltage, as a working cell needs.
Common mistake. Doubling the silver table value to match the doubled half-reaction. E°cell uses the values as printed.
Answer: Iron is the anode. Fe + 2Ag⁺ → Fe²⁺ + 2Ag. E°cell = +1.25 V
Question typeBuild a prediction table for several metals joined to copper
Use this when: The question lists several metals, each joined to the same copper half-cell, and asks for the anode and the voltage of each.
Example. Predict each cell when Co, Pb and Ag are joined in turn to a copper half-cell, all 1.0 mol/L. Table values: E°(Co²⁺/Co) = −0.28 V, E°(Pb²⁺/Pb) = −0.13 V, E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V and E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V. For each, name the anode and find E°cell. Put the cells in order from highest to lowest voltage.
- Compare each metal with copper.
Copper is not always the cathode. Compare the two table values every time. The lower value is the anode.
Co −0.28 V < Cu +0.34 V. Pb −0.13 V < Cu. Ag +0.80 V > Cu +0.34 V
- Cobalt and copper.
Cobalt is lower, so cobalt is the anode. Subtract anode from cathode.
+0.34 V − (−0.28 V) = +0.62 V
- Lead and copper.
Lead is lower, so lead is the anode.
+0.34 V − (−0.13 V) = +0.47 V
- Silver and copper.
Silver is higher than copper, so copper is the anode and silver is the cathode.
+0.80 V − (+0.34 V) = +0.46 V
- Write the table.
Put the cells in order from highest to lowest voltage.
Co/Cu +0.62 V, anode Co. Pb/Cu +0.47 V, anode Pb. Ag/Cu +0.46 V, anode Cu
Why this works. The same copper half-cell takes a different role depending on the partner. Against a lower value it is the cathode. Against a higher value it is the anode. Only the table values decide.
Check your answer. Every voltage is positive. A negative result would mean the roles were chosen the wrong way round.
Common mistake. Treating copper as the cathode every time. With silver, copper is the anode.
Answer: Co/Cu +0.62 V (anode Co), Pb/Cu +0.47 V (anode Pb), Ag/Cu +0.46 V (anode Cu). Order: Co/Cu, Pb/Cu, Ag/Cu
Question typeFind the error in a prediction and repair it
Use this when: The question gives a student’s prediction with a negative or odd voltage, and asks what went wrong and what the correct prediction is.
Example. A student joins a silver half-cell to a copper half-cell, both 1.0 mol/L. Table values: E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V and E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V. The student writes: “Copper is the cathode. E°cell = 0.34 − 0.80 = −0.46 V, so the cell will not work.” Find the error. Write the correct prediction.
- Check how the student chose the cathode.
The student assumed copper is always the cathode. The table value must decide.
Cu is +0.34 V. Ag is +0.80 V. Silver is higher
- Choose the roles again.
The higher value is the cathode. The lower value is the anode.
silver is the cathode and copper is the anode
- Subtract again.
Cathode value minus anode value.
E°cell = +0.80 V − (+0.34 V) = +0.46 V
- Say what the negative value meant.
A negative E°cell means the roles were swapped. The cell works in the other direction.
−0.46 V and +0.46 V are equal in size and opposite in sign
- Write the reaction.
Copper gives two electrons. Each silver ion takes one.
Cu + 2Ag⁺ → Cu²⁺ + 2Ag
Why this works. A voltaic cell always has a positive E°cell when the roles are right. A negative result is a signal to check the roles, not a result about the cell. Reversing the roles reverses the sign.
Check your answer. The two answers, −0.46 V and +0.46 V, have the same size. Only the roles differ.
Common mistake. Believing the cell will not work because the voltage came out negative. Swap the roles and recalculate.
Answer: Error: copper was treated as the cathode. Correct: silver is the cathode, copper is the anode, E°cell = +0.46 V. Reaction: Cu + 2Ag⁺ → Cu²⁺ + 2Ag
Question typePlan safe handling, storage and disposal
Use this when: The question names the solutions in a plan and asks for hazards, precautions, storage or disposal, each with a reason.
Example. A plan uses 1.0 mol/L silver nitrate and 1.0 mol/L nickel(II) sulfate. The supplied label notes say: silver nitrate stains skin, and nickel(II) compounds are harmful, including to water life. WHMIS is the Workplace Hazardous Materials Information System, which labels hazardous materials. Give a precaution for each hazard. Give a storage step and a disposal step, each with a reason.
- Read the label first.
Labels and safety data sheets tell you the hazards and the first aid. Read them before opening a bottle.
read the WHMIS label and the safety data sheet
- Match a precaution to the skin hazard.
Silver nitrate stains skin, so keep it off the skin.
wear gloves, goggles and an apron
- Match a precaution to the harm hazard.
Nickel(II) compounds are harmful, so avoid contact and keep them out of drains.
wear gloves and goggles, and wash hands afterward
- Plan the storage.
Closed, labelled containers stop spills and stop people from mixing up the solutions.
closed and labelled containers
- Plan the disposal.
Metal ions can harm water life and water treatment systems, so they must not go down the drain.
collect solutions with metal ions in a waste container and follow the school disposal plan
- Plan the strips.
The metal strips are not dissolved, so they can be rinsed, dried and reused.
rinse, dry and reuse the strips
Why this works. A complete safety plan covers three things: protection while you work, storage, and disposal. Each step has a reason that comes from a hazard on the label.
Check your answer. Every hazard in the label notes has a matching precaution, and every precaution has a reason.
Common mistake. Pouring dilute solutions down the drain because they look harmless. Metal ions still harm water life.
Answer: Read the label and sheet. Wear gloves, goggles and an apron. Store in closed, labelled containers. Collect the waste and do not pour it down the drain
Question typePlan a battery from cells in a row
Use this when: The question gives the voltage a device needs and the E°cell of one cell, and asks for the number of cells and a test for the plan.
Example. A device needs at least 5.0 V. One iron and copper cell has E°cell = +0.79 V. Cells are joined in a row. How many cells are needed? Name one test for the plan.
- Say how cells in a row add.
Cells in a row add their voltages. Divide the voltage needed by the voltage of one cell.
number of cells = voltage needed ÷ voltage of one cell
- Divide.
Keep one extra digit in the middle value.
5.0 V ÷ 0.79 V = 6.33
- Round up.
You cannot use part of a cell, and the voltage must be at least the need.
6.33 → 7 cells
- Check.
The next smaller number must fall short.
6 × 0.79 = 4.74 V, which is less than 5.0 V. 7 × 0.79 = 5.53 V ✓
- Plan a test.
The table gives the voltage at the start. The voltage falls as the reactants are used up.
record the voltage over time while the device runs, and revise the design if it falls below the need
Why this works. The table value is the voltage at standard conditions, at the start. A plan must say what test would show that the design really works. Mass, cost, leaks and lifetime are also part of the evidence.
Check your answer. 7 cells give 5.53 V, above 5.0 V. 6 cells give 4.74 V, below it.
Common mistake. Rounding 6.33 to 6. Round up so the voltage is enough. Rounding to the nearest number gives too few cells.
Answer: 7 cells (5.53 V). Test: record the voltage over time while the device runs
Question typeSort statements into prediction, observation and plan
Use this when: The question lists statements about an investigation and asks which one is a prediction, an observation or a plan, or why real values may differ.
Example. Sort each statement as a prediction, an observation or a plan. S1: The table gives +0.62 V for the Co and Cu cell. S2: The voltmeter reads 0.59 V. S3: We will record the voltage every 30 seconds for 5 minutes. S4: The cobalt strip will be the anode. Then name one way a real cell differs from the table conditions.
- Ask where each number or claim came from.
A prediction comes from the table. An observation comes from a measurement. A plan says how a measurement will be made.
table, meter, or method
- Sort S1 and S4.
Both come from table values and reasoning, not from a meter.
S1 prediction, S4 prediction
- Sort S2.
A voltmeter reading is a measurement.
S2 observation
- Sort S3.
S3 describes what will be done. It has no result.
S3 plan
- Name a difference from the table conditions.
The table values are for 1.0 mol/L solutions at 25.00 °C and 101.325 kPa. A real cell can differ from this.
for example, the solution is not exactly 1.0 mol/L, or the room is not 25.00 °C
Why this works. A prediction and a plan are not data. A prediction only becomes a test of an idea when it is compared with an observation. Real measurements differ a little from the table.
Check your answer. Each statement has exactly one label. The word “will” points to a prediction or a plan.
Common mistake. Calling a value from the table an observation. If it did not come from a meter, it is not an observation.
Answer: S1 prediction, S2 observation, S3 plan, S4 prediction. A real cell can differ in concentration or temperature
Diploma-style questions
Try each question first. Then open the worked solution.
Multiple choice · outcome 30-B1.1sA student joins different metals to a copper half-cell and reads the voltage of each cell. All solutions are 1.0 mol/L. Which choice names the dependent variable?
- A. The metal in the half-cell
- B. The voltage read on the voltmeter
- C. The concentration of the solutions
- D. The salt bridge
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
- Say what a dependent variable is.
It is the quantity you measure. It depends on what you changed.
- Sort the choices.
The metal is changed. The concentration and the salt bridge are kept the same. The voltage is measured.
A: changed. B: measured. C and D: kept the same
- Choose B.
The voltmeter reading is the dependent variable.
answer B
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A. The student chooses the metal and changes it. That makes it the independent variable.
- B. Correct. The voltage is the quantity that is read, so it is the dependent variable.
- C. The concentration is kept at 1.0 mol/L in every cell. It is a controlled variable.
- D. The same kind of salt bridge is used every time. It is a controlled variable.
Answer: B
Numerical response · outcome 30-B1.2sA cell joins a cobalt half-cell to a silver half-cell, both 1.0 mol/L. Table values: E°(Co²⁺/Co) = −0.28 V and E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V. Predict E°cell. Record your answer as a.bc V. Enter the digits a, b and c.
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
- Find the anode.
The lower table value is oxidized. Cobalt is the anode and silver is the cathode.
−0.28 V is lower than +0.80 V
- Subtract.
E°cell is the cathode value minus the anode value. Do not use a coefficient.
E°cell = +0.80 V − (−0.28 V) = +1.08 V
- Enter the digits.
The value is 1.08, so a = 1, b = 0 and c = 8.
record 1 0 8
Answer: +1.08 V. Record 1 0 8.
Numerical response · outcome 30-B2.1sA device needs at least 2.5 V. Each iron and copper cell has E°cell = +0.79 V. Cells are joined in a row. How many cells are needed? Record your answer as a whole number. Enter the digit.
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
- Divide.
Cells in a row add their voltages. Divide the voltage needed by the voltage of one cell.
2.5 V ÷ 0.79 V = 3.16
- Round up.
You cannot use part of a cell, and the voltage must reach the need.
3.16 → 4
- Check.
Three cells fall short and four are enough.
3 × 0.79 = 2.37 V. 4 × 0.79 = 3.16 V ✓
- Enter the digit.
The answer is a single digit.
record 4
Answer: 4 cells. Record 4.
Multiple choice · outcome 30-B1.2sA plan uses solutions that contain metal ions, such as silver nitrate. Which step is the correct disposal step?
- A. Pour the solution down the drain with plenty of water.
- B. Collect the solution in a labelled waste container and follow the school disposal plan.
- C. Leave the solution open on a bench so it evaporates.
- D. Mix it with the other waste solutions in a bucket.
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
- Say what the hazard is.
Metal ions can harm water life and water treatment systems.
- Sort the choices.
Only a collected, labelled waste container keeps the ions out of the water.
A and D put ions into the water or the garbage. C is not a disposal step
- Choose B.
Collect the solutions and follow the school disposal plan.
answer B
Why each choice is right or wrong
- A. Water does not remove metal ions. They still reach the water treatment system and can harm water life.
- B. Correct. A labelled waste container keeps the metal ions out of the water and lets the school dispose of them safely.
- C. An open solution can spill or stain, and the metal ions stay behind as a solid. It is not a disposal plan.
- D. Unknown mixing can cause unwanted reactions and makes safe disposal harder. Waste must be collected in labelled containers.
Answer: B