B15 · Investigation: analyze and explain · Notes and practice
Download the printable PDF
Put together given evidence, compare predictions with observations, explain differences, identify products and judge a battery design.
Open the complete lesson
Type in the blanks; your notes save on this device only. Use the backup controls at the bottom to keep a portable copy. Nothing is submitted.
1. Evidence and comparison
Put together the evidence
In B14 we predicted each voltage. Now we look at results. This lesson uses a sample set that we did not measure.
Pairs are predicted/measured: Zn 1.10/1.07 V, Fe 0.79/0.76 V, Ni 0.60/0.57 V, Ag 0.46/0.43 V. Each row is one cell.
A good table has a title, in the headings, the predicted column and the measured column. Note the controlled conditions too.
The measured column holds , because those numbers came from a voltmeter. The predicted column holds values from the reduction table.
On the diploma: a common wrong choice mixes up observation and prediction. Ask which column came from a measurement.
Compare
Difference = predicted − . Each cell here is V lower than the prediction. That is a pattern with a direction and a size.
The order also matches, with zinc highest and silver lowest. So the data the table. We say support, not prove.
A percent difference compares the gap with the prediction. For zinc, 0.03 ÷ 1.10 × 100 = %. A small gap means close agreement.
On the diploma: describe a pattern with its direction and size, with the unit. Do not just say the numbers are close.
2. Explain, identify and evaluate
Explain a difference
Three possible causes fit a constant gap: the salt bridge adds , the strips have coatings, or the concentration is not exactly 1.0 mol/L.
Temperature is another, because the table assumes 25 °C. A good report records the room temperature and the concentration.
To test a cause, change thing and measure again. For example, sand the strips and see if the voltage rises toward the prediction.
Until the test is done, the cause is , not proven. On the diploma: never claim a cause that was not tested.
Identify products
In the Zn/Cu cell, the zinc strip loses mass, so zinc is oxidized. The copper strip gains a coating, so copper ions are reduced.
An observation is what we see or measure. An inference is a conclusion drawn from it. Zn²⁺ is colourless, so it is an .
In the Ag/Cu cell, copper is the anode. The copper strip loses mass, and the copper solution is already blue, so it gets blue as Cu²⁺ forms.
A conclusion has a , the evidence and an explanation. Name a limitation and an , such as three trials averaged.
On the diploma: to identify a product, name the observation that supports it.
Battery design and disposal
Three cells of 1.07 V give 3 × 1.07 = . Judge voltage, mass, cost, lifetime and , because voltage is only one part of the evidence.
Used batteries contain metals that can harm soil and water, so they are collected for . Recycling has benefits and costs, like the energy it needs.
A hydrogen fuel cell gives about 1.23 V per cell. A fair presentation gives purpose, reactions, benefits and , and states the source of its evidence.
On the diploma: to evaluate a technology, name evidence that supports it and a limit that remains.
Use the diagram response box for labels and arrows in words, or draw on the printable PDF.
Answer the 12 core practice problems online · Completed notes and worked key
B15-P01
Name three things that a good data table includes.
Response: ____________________
B15-P02
Which column of the table holds observations and which holds predictions? Explain.
Response: ____________________
B15-P03
Given a given result for zinc and copper: predicted 1.10 V, measured 1.07 V. Find the difference.
Response: ____________________
B15-P04
All four given cells are 0.03 V below the prediction and the order matches. Does the data support the table? Give a reason.
Response: ____________________
B15-P05
Give two possible explanations for a small constant gap and say how to test one of them.
Response: ____________________
B15-P06
Explain why a possible cause should not be stated as proven before a test.
Response: ____________________
B15-P07
In a zinc and copper cell the zinc strip loses mass and the copper strip gains a reddish-brown coating. State two observations and the half-reactions they support.
Response: ____________________
B15-P08
Zn²⁺(aq) is colourless. Is its formation an observation or an inference? Explain.
Response: ____________________
B15-P09
Given a given nickel and copper result: predicted 0.60 V, measured 0.57 V. Write a short conclusion with a claim, evidence and one possible explanation.
Response: ____________________
B15-P10
A design uses one trial for each cell. Give one limitation and one improvement.
Response: ____________________
B15-P11
Four cells of 1.07 V are joined in a row. Find the battery voltage and name one disposal step for the used battery.
Response: ____________________
B15-P12
Name two parts that a short fuel cell presentation must include, and say why the source of evidence should be stated.
Response: ____________________