B15 · Investigation: analyze and explain · Answer key

Download the printable PDF

Put together given evidence, compare predictions with observations, explain differences, identify products and judge a battery design.

Open the complete lesson

1. Evidence and comparison

Put together the evidence

In B14 we predicted each voltage. Now we look at results. This lesson uses a supplied sample set that we did not measure.

Pairs are predicted/measured: Zn 1.10/1.07 V, Fe 0.79/0.76 V, Ni 0.60/0.57 V, Ag 0.46/0.43 V. Each row is one cell.

A good table has a title, units in the headings, the predicted column and the measured column. Note the controlled conditions too.

The measured column holds observations, because those numbers came from a voltmeter. The predicted column holds values from the reduction table.

On the diploma: a common wrong choice mixes up observation and prediction. Ask which column came from a measurement.

Compare

Difference = predicted − measured. Each cell here is 0.03 V lower than the prediction. That is a pattern with a direction and a size.

The order also matches, with zinc highest and silver lowest. So the data support the table. We say support, not prove.

A percent difference compares the gap with the prediction. For zinc, 0.03 ÷ 1.10 × 100 = 2.7 %. A small gap means close agreement.

On the diploma: describe a pattern with its direction and size, with the unit. Do not just say the numbers are close.

2. Explain, identify and evaluate

Explain a difference

Three possible causes fit a constant gap: the salt bridge adds resistance, the strips have oxide coatings, or the concentration is not exactly 1.0 mol/L.

Temperature is another, because the table assumes 25 °C. A good report records the room temperature and the concentration.

To test a cause, change one thing and measure again. For example, sand the strips and see if the voltage rises toward the prediction.

Until the test is done, the cause is possible, not proven. On the diploma: never claim a cause that was not tested.

Identify products

In the Zn/Cu cell, the zinc strip loses mass, so zinc is oxidized. The copper strip gains a reddish-brown coating, so copper ions are reduced.

An observation is what we see or measure. An inference is a conclusion drawn from it. Zn²⁺ is colourless, so it is an inference.

In the Ag/Cu cell, copper is the anode. The copper strip loses mass, and the copper solution is already blue, so it gets deeper blue as Cu²⁺ forms.

A conclusion has a claim, the evidence and an explanation. Name a limitation and an improvement, such as three trials averaged.

On the diploma: to identify a product, name the observation that supports it.

Battery design and disposal

Three cells of 1.07 V give 3 × 1.07 = 3.21 V. Judge voltage, mass, cost, lifetime and leaks, because voltage is only one part of the evidence.

Used batteries contain metals that can harm soil and water, so they are collected for recycling. Recycling has benefits and costs, like the energy it needs.

A hydrogen fuel cell gives about 1.23 V per cell. A fair presentation gives purpose, reactions, benefits and limits, and states the source of its evidence.

On the diploma: to evaluate a technology, name evidence that supports it and a limit that remains.

The completed diagram and text above answer the same labels as the student copy.

Answer the 12 core practice problems online · Completed notes and worked key

B15-P01

Name three things that a good data table includes.

  1. A title, headings with units, and the predicted values beside the measured values.
  2. The controlled conditions should also be noted so that a reader can judge the test.

B15-P02

Which column of the table holds observations and which holds predictions? Explain.

  1. The measured column holds observations, because they come from measuring.
  2. The predicted column holds values from the reduction table.

B15-P03

Given a given result for zinc and copper: predicted 1.10 V, measured 1.07 V. Find the difference.

  1. The difference is predicted minus measured.
  2. 1.10 − 1.07 = 0.03 V, so the measured value is 0.03 V lower.

B15-P04

All four given cells are 0.03 V below the prediction and the order matches. Does the data support the table? Give a reason.

  1. Yes. The order of the voltages is the same as predicted.
  2. Each value is within 0.03 V of the prediction, so the table predicts the order and the size well.

B15-P05

Give two possible explanations for a small constant gap and say how to test one of them.

  1. The salt bridge adds resistance, and the strips may have an oxide coating.
  2. Sand the strips, measure again and see if the voltage moves closer to the prediction. Change only one thing.

B15-P06

Explain why a possible cause should not be stated as proven before a test.

  1. A possible cause fits the evidence but has not been tested.
  2. Only a test that changes one thing shows if that thing causes the gap.

B15-P07

In a zinc and copper cell the zinc strip loses mass and the copper strip gains a reddish-brown coating. State two observations and the half-reactions they support.

  1. Observations: the zinc loses mass and the copper gains a coating.
  2. Zn → Zn²⁺ + 2e⁻ and Cu²⁺ + 2e⁻ → Cu.

B15-P08

Zn²⁺(aq) is colourless. Is its formation an observation or an inference? Explain.

  1. It is an inference, not an observation.
  2. You cannot see the ions. You reason that they form because the zinc strip loses mass.

B15-P09

Given a given nickel and copper result: predicted 0.60 V, measured 0.57 V. Write a short conclusion with a claim, evidence and one possible explanation.

  1. Claim: the result agrees with the table. Evidence: 0.57 V against 0.60 V and the strip changes.
  2. Explanation: the salt bridge or an oxide coating could lower the voltage a little.

B15-P10

A design uses one trial for each cell. Give one limitation and one improvement.

  1. One trial cannot show how much the measurement varies.
  2. Repeat three trials and take the average, and clean the strips before each trial.

B15-P11

Four cells of 1.07 V are joined in a row. Find the battery voltage and name one disposal step for the used battery.

  1. The voltages add: 4 × 1.07 = 4.28 V.
  2. Collect the used battery for recycling. Do not put it in the garbage, because it contains metals that can harm soil and water.

B15-P12

Name two parts that a short fuel cell presentation must include, and say why the source of evidence should be stated.

  1. Include any two of the purpose, the half-reactions, the benefits and the limits.
  2. The source lets a reader check the claims. A claim without evidence cannot be judged.