B4 · Worked examples

These questions ask which way a redox reaction goes. You rank agents from evidence, choose the roles from the species present, and subtract table values. You also plan and judge investigations.

Open the B4 lesson · B4 slide notes

Worked question types

Each example shows every step, why you do it, and the idea behind it.

Question type

Rank agents from observations

Use this when: The question gives model observations from metals placed in ion solutions and asks you to rank the reducing agents or the oxidizing agents.

Example. Model results: zinc in Cu²⁺ gives a reddish deposit. Copper in Ag⁺ gives a silver deposit. Copper in Zn²⁺ gives no deposit. Rank the metals as reducing agents. Rank the ions as oxidizing agents.
  1. Say what a deposit means.

    A new metal coating means the dissolved ions gained electrons and became metal. The electrons came from the metal that dissolved.

    deposit = ion reduced, metal oxidized

  2. Write each pair.

    The metal that gave electrons is the stronger reducing agent in that pair.

    Zn gave to Cu²⁺: Zn > Cu. Cu gave to Ag⁺: Cu > Ag

  3. Link the pairs through the shared metal.

    Copper appears in both pairs, so it joins the two comparisons.

    Zn > Cu > Ag as reducing agents

  4. Rank the ions the other way round.

    The ion of the weakest reducing agent is the strongest oxidizing agent. A metal and its ion have different roles.

    Ag⁺ > Cu²⁺ > Zn²⁺ as oxidizing agents

  5. Check against the no-change result.

    Cu did not reduce Zn²⁺. That matches Zn being the stronger reducing agent.

    Cu with Zn²⁺: no deposit ✓

  6. Name the exact species.

    Write Ag⁺, not just silver.

    reducing agents: Zn, Cu, Ag. oxidizing agents: Ag⁺, Cu²⁺, Zn²⁺

Why this works. A metal that displaces another metal’s ion is the stronger reducing agent. Putting these comparisons in a chain gives a full ranking. The ions rank in the opposite order, because a strong reducing agent has an ion that is a weak oxidizing agent.

Check your answer. The two lists are mirror images: the strongest reducing agent Zn pairs with the weakest oxidizing agent Zn²⁺.

Common mistake. Using the same order for the metals and for the ions. They run the opposite way.

Answer: Reducing agents: Zn > Cu > Ag. Oxidizing agents: Ag⁺ > Cu²⁺ > Zn²⁺

Question type

Select the strongest pair from a mixture, then predict

Use this when: The question lists the species in a beaker, gives table values, and asks which reaction starts first and its E°reaction.

Example. A beaker holds Cu(s), Zn²⁺(aq), Ag⁺(aq) and Ag(s). Table values: E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V, E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V, E°(Zn²⁺/Zn) = −0.76 V. Choose the strongest oxidizing agent and reducing agent that are present. Write the reaction and find E°reaction.
  1. List the possible oxidizing agents.

    Oxidizing agents are the ions that can gain electrons. Use only what is in the beaker.

    Zn²⁺ (−0.76 V) and Ag⁺ (+0.80 V)

  2. Pick the strongest oxidizing agent.

    The more positive table value pulls harder on electrons.

    Ag⁺ is the strongest oxidizing agent present

  3. List the possible reducing agents.

    Reducing agents are the metals present. A metal donates by running its row backwards, so the lower value is the stronger reducing agent.

    Cu (+0.34 V) and Ag (+0.80 V)

  4. Pick the strongest reducing agent.

    The lower table value means the metal gives up electrons more easily.

    Cu is the strongest reducing agent present

  5. Write the reaction.

    Cu loses 2 electrons. Each Ag⁺ gains 1. So one Cu needs 2 Ag⁺.

    Cu + 2Ag⁺ → Cu²⁺ + 2Ag

  6. Subtract, oxidizing agent minus reducing agent pair.

    The oxidizing agent is Ag⁺ and the reducing agent pair is Cu²⁺/Cu.

    E°reaction = +0.80 − (+0.34) = +0.46 V

Why this works. You can only choose from species that are really in the beaker. A strong oxidizing agent that is not present is like a player who did not show up. Choose the roles first, then write the reaction.

Check your answer. The sign is positive, so the written direction is spontaneous under standard conditions.

Common mistake. Picking Zn as the reducing agent because it has the lowest value in the table. Zn is not in the beaker.

Answer: Cu + 2Ag⁺ → Cu²⁺ + 2Ag, E°reaction = +0.46 V

Question type

Find E°reaction with the table and decide if the reaction is spontaneous

Use this when: The question gives a full reaction and table values and asks for E°reaction and whether it is spontaneous.

Example. Table values: E°(H⁺/H₂) = 0.00 V and E°(Zn²⁺/Zn) = −0.76 V. Find E°reaction for Zn + 2H⁺ → Zn²⁺ + H₂. Is the written direction spontaneous?
  1. Name the oxidizing agent and the reducing agent.

    Use Method: how to predict a redox reaction with the table. Zn goes from 0 to +2, so it loses electrons. H⁺ gains them.

    reducing agent: Zn oxidizing agent: H⁺

  2. Find each table value.

    Use the reduction value for the oxidizing agent, and for the reducing agent’s pair.

    oxidizing agent H⁺/H₂: 0.00 V reducing agent pair Zn²⁺/Zn: −0.76 V

  3. Subtract.

    E°reaction, the voltage number for the whole reaction, is the oxidizing agent minus the reducing agent pair. The reducing agent runs backwards, so we subtract.

    E°reaction = 0.00 − (−0.76) = +0.76 V

  4. Do not multiply by the coefficient 2.

    E°reaction is energy per charge. Doubling the amount does not change it.

    still +0.76 V

  5. Read the sign.

    A positive value means the written direction is spontaneous under standard conditions.

    spontaneous, but this says nothing about speed

Why this works. Every table value is measured from the same starting point, the standard hydrogen electrode, which is 0.00 V. A positive result means the electrons flow from the reducing agent to the oxidizing agent in the direction written.

Check your answer. Zn is lower in the table than hydrogen, so it is the stronger reducing agent. A positive E°reaction agrees with that.

Common mistake. Taking the larger value minus the smaller one every time. First choose the roles, then subtract.

Answer: E°reaction = +0.76 V, spontaneous

Question type

Check the direction and repair a reaction

Use this when: The question gives a reaction as written, often in the wrong direction, and asks if it is spontaneous or what the spontaneous reaction is.

Example. A student proposes 2Ag + Cu²⁺ → 2Ag⁺ + Cu. Table values: E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V and E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V. Is it spontaneous? If not, write the spontaneous reaction.
  1. Name the roles in the proposed reaction.

    Ag goes from 0 to +1, so Ag is the reducing agent. Cu²⁺ is the oxidizing agent.

    reducing agent: Ag oxidizing agent: Cu²⁺

  2. Subtract.

    Oxidizing agent minus reducing agent pair.

    E°reaction = +0.34 − (+0.80) = −0.46 V

  3. Read the sign.

    A negative value means the reverse is spontaneous.

    the proposed direction is not spontaneous

  4. Write the reverse reaction.

    Swap the reactants and products.

    Cu + 2Ag⁺ → Cu²⁺ + 2Ag

  5. Find E°reaction for the reverse.

    Now the oxidizing agent is Ag⁺ and the reducing agent pair is Cu²⁺/Cu.

    E°reaction = +0.80 − (+0.34) = +0.46 V

  6. Say what the sign does not tell you.

    The sign gives direction, not speed. A reaction with no visible change in a short time is not proved impossible.

    direction only

Why this works. Reversing a reaction flips the sign of E°reaction. So a negative E°reaction for one direction means the opposite direction is spontaneous, with the same size.

Check your answer. The two values are +0.46 V and −0.46 V, equal in size and opposite in sign.

Common mistake. Always taking larger minus smaller. That hides the roles and gives a positive answer for the wrong direction.

Answer: Not spontaneous (−0.46 V). Spontaneous: Cu + 2Ag⁺ → Cu²⁺ + 2Ag, E°reaction = +0.46 V

Question type

Keep E°reaction the same when the coefficients change

Use this when: The question gives a reaction with coefficients (such as 2Ag⁺) and a student answer that multiplied a table value.

Example. For Zn + 2Ag⁺ → Zn²⁺ + 2Ag, a student calculates E°reaction = 2(+0.80) − (−0.76). Find the correct E°reaction and explain the error.
  1. Name the roles.

    Zn is the reducing agent and Ag⁺ is the oxidizing agent.

    reducing agent: Zn oxidizing agent: Ag⁺

  2. Find the student’s answer.

    The student multiplied the table value by 2.

    2(+0.80) − (−0.76) = +2.36 V

  3. Say what E°reaction measures.

    Volts are joules per coulomb. This is a ratio, so it does not depend on how many particles react.

    E°reaction is energy per charge

  4. Use the table values as printed.

    Do not multiply by coefficients.

    E°reaction = +0.80 − (−0.76) = +1.56 V

  5. Check with a different amount.

    Write the reaction for one Ag⁺ and half a Zn. The potential must be the same.

    ½Zn + Ag⁺ → ½Zn²⁺ + Ag has E°reaction = +1.56 V

Why this works. A table value is the energy given to each coulomb of charge that moves. Doubling a reaction doubles the charge and the energy, but the energy per coulomb stays the same.

Check your answer. The student’s +2.36 V is larger than any table difference, which is a sign of a mistake.

Common mistake. Multiplying the table value by the coefficient. E°reaction never changes when you change the coefficients.

Answer: E°reaction = +1.56 V. The student multiplied a table value

Question type

Use volts as energy per charge

Use this when: The question gives energy and charge, or a potential and a charge, and asks for the missing quantity.

Example. A cell transfers 270 J of energy when 180 C of charge moves. Find the potential difference. How much energy is transferred when 40 C moves at the same potential difference?
  1. Write the meaning of a volt.

    One volt is one joule of energy for every coulomb of charge.

    V = E ÷ Q

  2. Substitute.

    Divide the energy by the charge.

    V = 270 J ÷ 180 C = 1.50 V

  3. Rearrange for energy.

    Multiply both sides by Q.

    E = V × Q

  4. Substitute the new charge.

    Use the same potential difference.

    E = 1.50 V × 40 C = 60.0 J

  5. Check with the first case.

    Per coulomb, both cases should give the same ratio.

    270 ÷ 180 = 60.0 ÷ 40 = 1.50 ✓

Why this works. A potential difference compares energy with charge. Doubling both the energy and the charge leaves the ratio the same. That is why E°reaction does not depend on how much material reacts.

Check your answer. More charge means more energy at the same potential, so 40 C needs less than 180 C. 60 J is less than 270 J ✓.

Common mistake. Treating volts as energy. A volt is energy per charge, so you must divide by the charge.

Answer: 1.50 V, and 60.0 J

Question type

Plan a fair virtual investigation

Use this when: The question asks you to plan a test of metals and ions, name what to change and what to keep the same, and say what controls are needed.

Example. You will compare the metals Zn, Cu and Ag with the ions Zn²⁺, Cu²⁺ and Ag⁺ in a virtual investigation. Plan a fair test. State what you change, what you hold constant, and which trials are controls. How many trials are there?
  1. State the question.

    A good test compares one thing at a time.

    Which metal gives electrons to which ion?

  2. Say what you change.

    Change only the metal–ion pair, one pair per trial.

    the metal and its partner ion

  3. Hold everything else constant.

    If other things change, you cannot tell what caused the result.

    concentration 1.0 mol/L, volume 50.0 mL, temperature 25.0 °C, surface area 2.0 cm², time 5.0 min

  4. Count the trials.

    Each metal goes with each ion.

    3 × 3 = 9 trials

  5. Pick the controls.

    A control uses the same metal and its own ion, such as Cu in Cu²⁺. No change is expected.

    3 controls and 6 test trials

  6. Say what you will record.

    Record what you see, such as a deposit or a colour change. Do not record explanations as observations.

    observations only

Why this works. A fair test changes one thing and holds the rest constant. The control shows that a deposit comes from the pair being tested, not from the setup. The model is fixed, so repeating it does not measure real uncertainty.

Check your answer. The numbers add up: 6 test trials plus 3 controls make 9.

Common mistake. Changing the volume or the time between trials. Then you cannot say what caused a difference.

Answer: 9 trials: 6 tests and 3 controls. Change: the metal–ion pair. Hold constant: concentration, volume, temperature, surface area and time

Question type

Write a claim that is supported by evidence

Use this when: The question gives observations and asks for a conclusion with a claim, the evidence and an electron-transfer inference.

Example. Model observations: copper in Ag⁺ gives a silver-coloured deposit and the solution turns blue. Copper in Zn²⁺ shows no change in 5.0 min. Write a claim about the reducing agents and support it.
  1. Separate observations from inferences.

    An observation is what you see. An inference is what you decide it means.

    observed: deposit, blue colour, no change. inferred: electrons moved

  2. Write the claim.

    Name the metals and the ions.

    Cu is a stronger reducing agent than Ag.

  3. Give the evidence.

    Quote the actual observations.

    In Ag⁺, copper gave a silver deposit and the blue colour of Cu²⁺ appeared. In Zn²⁺, there was no change in 5.0 min.

  4. Add the electron-transfer inference.

    Say who gave and who took the electrons.

    Cu gave electrons to Ag⁺, which became Ag. Cu became Cu²⁺, which is blue.

  5. State the limit.

    No change in a short time does not prove no reaction. It might be too slow to see.

    The Zn²⁺ result supports, but does not prove, that Zn is the stronger reducing agent.

Why this works. A good conclusion has three parts: a claim, the evidence for it, and an inference about electrons. The inference explains the evidence. It is never listed as an observation.

Check your answer. Every part of your answer should point back to something in the observations.

Common mistake. Writing “copper is stronger” and stopping. A claim needs evidence and an electron-transfer inference.

Answer: Cu is a stronger reducing agent than Ag. Evidence and inference as above

Diploma-style questions

Try each question first. Then open the worked solution.

Numerical response · outcome 30-B1.5k
Table values: E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V and E°(Zn²⁺/Zn) = −0.76 V. Find E°reaction for Zn + 2Ag⁺ → Zn²⁺ + 2Ag. Record your answer as a.bc V. Enter the digits a, b and c.
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
  1. Name the roles.

    Zn is the reducing agent and Ag⁺ is the oxidizing agent.

    reducing agent: Zn oxidizing agent: Ag⁺

  2. Subtract.

    Oxidizing agent minus reducing agent pair. Do not multiply by the coefficient 2.

    E°reaction = +0.80 − (−0.76) = +1.56 V

  3. Enter the digits.

    The value is 1.56, so a = 1, b = 5 and c = 6.

    record 1 5 6

Answer: +1.56 V. Record 1 5 6.

Multiple choice · outcome 30-B1.6k
Using standard table values, which reaction is spontaneous as written? Table values: E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V, E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V, E°(H⁺/H₂) = 0.00 V, E°(Zn²⁺/Zn) = −0.76 V.
  1. A. Cu + Zn²⁺ → Cu²⁺ + Zn
  2. B. Cu + 2H⁺ → Cu²⁺ + H₂
  3. C. Zn + Cu²⁺ → Zn²⁺ + Cu
  4. D. 2Ag + Cu²⁺ → 2Ag⁺ + Cu
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
  1. Choose the roles in each option.

    The reducing agent is the species that is oxidized. The oxidizing agent is the one that is reduced.

  2. Subtract for each.

    Oxidizing agent minus reducing agent pair.

    A: −1.10 V B: −0.34 V C: +1.10 V D: −0.46 V

  3. Choose the positive one.

    Only a positive E°reaction means the direction written is spontaneous.

    answer C

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A. The oxidizing agent is Zn²⁺ (−0.76 V) and the reducing agent pair is Cu²⁺/Cu (+0.34 V). E°reaction = −1.10 V. The reverse is spontaneous.
  • B. The oxidizing agent is H⁺ (0.00 V) and the reducing agent pair is Cu²⁺/Cu (+0.34 V). E°reaction = −0.34 V. Copper does not react with H⁺.
  • C. Correct. The oxidizing agent is Cu²⁺ (+0.34 V) and the reducing agent pair is Zn²⁺/Zn (−0.76 V). E°reaction = +1.10 V.
  • D. The oxidizing agent is Cu²⁺ (+0.34 V) and the reducing agent pair is Ag⁺/Ag (+0.80 V). E°reaction = −0.46 V. The reverse is spontaneous.

Answer: C

Multiple choice · outcome 30-B1.3s
A zinc strip is placed in blue Cu²⁺ solution for 5.0 min. A reddish solid forms and the blue colour weakens. Which statement is an inference and not an observation?
  1. A. A reddish solid forms on the zinc.
  2. B. The blue colour of the solution weakens.
  3. C. Zinc is a stronger reducing agent than copper.
  4. D. The zinc strip stays in the solution for 5.0 min.
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
  1. Sort the statements.

    An observation is what you can see or measure. An inference is a meaning you decide on.

    A, B and D are seen or measured. C is a decision about electrons

  2. Choose C.

    Saying zinc is a stronger reducing agent uses the idea of electron transfer.

    answer C

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A. You can see a reddish solid. This is an observation.
  • B. You can see the colour fade. This is an observation.
  • C. Correct. “Stronger reducing agent” is an explanation built on the idea of electron transfer. It is an inference.
  • D. The time of 5.0 min is measured. This is an observation.

Answer: C