B4 · Predict reactions and investigate · Completed notes
Download the printable PDF
Goals: Rank reducing agents and oxidizing agents from test results. Predict which way a reaction goes under standard conditions, using the Data Booklet table. Plan a virtual investigation and say what its results can and cannot show.
Slide 1 of 11 · Balanced does not mean spontaneous
Key ideas
Zn + Cu²⁺ → Zn²⁺ + Cu and its reverse both balance for atoms and charge. Balancing cannot tell which direction happens.
A direction is spontaneous if it happens by itself, with no outside push of energy.
Spontaneous does not mean fast. A spontaneous reaction can still be slow.
To choose a direction we need evidence about which substance gives electrons more easily.
Example
Show that Zn + Cu²⁺ → Zn²⁺ + Cu and its reverse both balance. Can the balanced equation alone tell you which direction is spontaneous under standard conditions?
- Forward: Zn 1 = 1; Cu 1 = 1; charge +2 = +2. It balances.
- Reverse: Zn 1 = 1; Cu 1 = 1; charge +2 = +2. It also balances.
- Both directions balance for atoms and charge, so balancing cannot choose a direction.
- We need evidence about reducing agents and oxidizing agents, which comes next.
Try it
A reaction is spontaneous under standard conditions, but a student sees no change after one minute. Is that a contradiction? Explain.
- No. Spontaneous means it happens by itself, with no outside push of energy.
- It does not mean fast. A spontaneous reaction can still be slow.
Slide 2 of 11 · From observations to reducing-agent strength
Key ideas
Example test results: Zn in Cu²⁺ gives a copper deposit. Cu in Ag⁺ gives a silver deposit. Cu in Zn²⁺ shows no change.
A copper deposit means Cu²⁺ gained electrons. The electrons came from zinc, so zinc is the stronger reducing agent.
Zn beats Cu and Cu beats Ag, so the order of reducing agents is Zn > Cu > Ag. Read > as "is a stronger reducing agent than".
To keep the test fair, control the solution, temperature, strip area and time.
Example
Given these example test results: Zn in Cu²⁺ gives a copper deposit; Cu in Ag⁺ gives a silver deposit; Cu in Zn²⁺ gives no change. Rank Zn, Cu and Ag as reducing agents.
- Zn gives electrons to Cu²⁺, so Zn is a stronger reducing agent than Cu.
- Cu gives electrons to Ag⁺, so Cu is a stronger reducing agent than Ag.
- Copper links the two comparisons: Zn > Cu > Ag.
- Cu in Zn²⁺ shows no change, which agrees with this order.
Try it
Given these example test results: Fe in Cu²⁺ gives a copper deposit; Zn in Fe²⁺ gives an iron deposit. Rank Zn, Fe and Cu as reducing agents.
- Fe gives electrons to Cu²⁺, so Fe is a stronger reducing agent than Cu.
- Zn gives electrons to Fe²⁺, so Zn is a stronger reducing agent than Fe.
- Order of reducing agents: Zn > Fe > Cu.
Slide 3 of 11 · Keep reducing agents and oxidizing agents in separate columns
Key ideas
The metals are reducing agents: Zn > Cu > Ag. Their ions are oxidizing agents, and they rank the opposite way: Ag⁺ > Cu²⁺ > Zn²⁺.
Write the exact formula with its charge, such as Ag⁺, not just silver.
Written as reductions, the strongest oxidizing agent goes at the top. The strongest reducing agent is then at the bottom right.
List what is in the beaker: every ion, any metal, and water. An acidic or “acidified” solution also has H⁺. A basic solution has OH⁻.
Example
For the same pairs, the reducing agents rank Zn > Cu > Ag. Rank Ag⁺, Cu²⁺ and Zn²⁺ as oxidizing agents and explain why the two lists run oppositely.
- Oxidizing agents: Ag⁺ > Cu²⁺ > Zn²⁺.
- Zn gives up electrons most easily, so Zn²⁺ is least willing to take them back.
- Ag gives up electrons least easily, so Ag⁺ is most willing to take them.
Try it
Given: Fe gives electrons to Cu²⁺, and Zn gives electrons to Fe²⁺. Rank Zn²⁺, Fe²⁺ and Cu²⁺ as oxidizing agents.
- Reducing agents: Zn > Fe > Cu.
- The ions run the opposite way: Cu²⁺ > Fe²⁺ > Zn²⁺.
Slide 4 of 11 · Read the Alberta reduction table
Key ideas
Every table row is a reduction: something gains electrons. The number is E°, in volts.
The oxidizing agents are on the left. The strongest is at the top. The reducing agents are on the right. The strongest is at the bottom.
A higher E° means a stronger oxidizing agent. So Ag⁺ is stronger than Cu²⁺. E° predicts direction, not speed.
Standard conditions are 1.0 mol/L solutions, 25.00 °C and 101.325 kPa for gases. The table is on Data Booklet page 7.
Example
Given from the Alberta Data Booklet: E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V, E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V and E°(Zn²⁺/Zn) = −0.76 V. Which ion pulls electrons most strongly, and which metal is the strongest reducing agent?
- The highest E° is +0.80 V, so Ag⁺ pulls electrons most strongly.
- The lowest E° is −0.76 V, so Zn²⁺ pulls electrons least. Its metal, Zn, is the strongest reducing agent.
- These values are for standard conditions: 1.0 mol/L, 25.00 °C and 101.325 kPa for gases.
Try it
Given: E°(Mg²⁺/Mg) = −2.37 V, E°(Fe²⁺/Fe) = −0.45 V and E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V. Which metal is the strongest reducing agent, and which ion is the strongest oxidizing agent?
- The lowest E° is −2.37 V (Mg²⁺/Mg), so Mg is the strongest reducing agent.
- The highest E° is +0.34 V (Cu²⁺/Cu), so Cu²⁺ is the strongest oxidizing agent.
Slide 5 of 11 · What the potential comparison means
Key ideas
One volt is one joule per coulomb. A coulomb (C) is a unit of electric charge.
Voltage is energy per charge: 150 J ÷ 100 C = 1.50 V. Doubling both energy and charge gives the same voltage.
Every table value is compared with the standard hydrogen electrode, which is defined as 0.00 V.
E°reaction = E°(oxidizing agent) − E°(reducing agent). A positive value means the written direction is spontaneous. A negative value means the reverse is spontaneous.
Example
The table lists E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V and E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V. What baseline do these numbers compare to? If Ag⁺ is the oxidizing agent and Cu is the reducing agent, what is E°reaction?
- Both values are compared with the standard hydrogen electrode, defined as 0.00 V.
- E°reaction = E°(oxidizing agent) − E°(reducing agent) = +0.80 − (+0.34) = +0.46 V.
- The value is positive, so the written direction is spontaneous under standard conditions.
Try it
A reaction transfers 240 J of energy for every 160 C of charge. What is the potential difference in volts? What is it if the energy and the charge both triple?
- 240 J ÷ 160 C = 1.50 J/C, which is 1.50 V.
- Tripled: 720 J ÷ 480 C = 1.50 J/C, which is still 1.50 V.
- Voltage is a ratio, so scaling both does not change it.
Slide 6 of 11 · Complete prediction: copper with silver ions
Key ideas
Ag⁺ is the oxidizing agent. Cu is the reducing agent, so read its row backwards: Cu → Cu²⁺ + 2e⁻. In the table, Ag⁺ on the left is above Cu on the right, so the reaction is spontaneous.
Multiply the silver half by 2, add and cancel the 2e⁻: Cu + 2Ag⁺ → Cu²⁺ + 2Ag.
E°reaction = E°(oxidizing agent) − E°(reducing agent) = +0.80 − (+0.34) = +0.46 V. Positive means the written direction is spontaneous.
Do not multiply E° by a coefficient. Predict a silver coating, a shrinking copper strip and a blue solution from Cu²⁺ (Data Booklet colours, printed p. 11).
Example
Given Cu(s) and Ag⁺(aq) under standard conditions, with E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V and E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V. Predict whether the reaction is spontaneous, write the net ionic equation and predict what you would see.
- Ag⁺ is the oxidizing agent: Ag⁺ + e⁻ → Ag. Cu is the reducing agent: Cu → Cu²⁺ + 2e⁻.
- Multiply the silver half by 2 and add: Cu + 2Ag⁺ → Cu²⁺ + 2Ag.
- E°reaction = +0.80 − (+0.34) = +0.46 V. It is positive, so it is spontaneous.
- Check: charge +2 = +2; atoms Cu 1 and Ag 2 on each side.
- Predictions: silver coating forms, the copper strip shrinks and Cu²⁺ makes the solution blue.
Try it
Given Mg(s) and Cu²⁺(aq) under standard conditions, with E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V and E°(Mg²⁺/Mg) = −2.37 V. Predict whether the reaction is spontaneous and write the net ionic equation.
- Cu²⁺ is the oxidizing agent: Cu²⁺ + 2e⁻ → Cu. Mg is the reducing agent: Mg → Mg²⁺ + 2e⁻.
- Both halves use 2e⁻, so add: Mg + Cu²⁺ → Mg²⁺ + Cu.
- E°reaction = +0.34 − (−2.37) = +2.71 V. It is positive, so it is spontaneous.
- Check: charge +2 = +2; atoms Mg 1 and Cu 1 on each side.
Slide 7 of 11 · Method: how to predict a redox reaction with the table
Key ideas
Step 1. List what is in the beaker: every ion, any metal, and water. Add H⁺ if it is acidic and OH⁻ if it is basic.
Step 2. Find the strongest oxidizing agent (highest on the left) and the strongest reducing agent (lowest on the right).
Step 3. Write the two halves. Reverse the reducing agent’s row so it is an oxidation.
Step 4. Calculate E°reaction = E°(oxidizing agent) − E°(reducing agent).
Step 5. A positive E°reaction is spontaneous. A negative E°reaction is not spontaneous.
Check: never multiply E° by a coefficient.
Example
Use the method on Cu(s) and Ag⁺(aq) with E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V and E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V. Is the reaction spontaneous?
- Step 1: the beaker has Cu(s) and Ag⁺(aq).
- Step 2: Ag⁺ is the oxidizing agent. Cu is the reducing agent. Ag⁺ is above Cu.
- Step 3: Ag⁺ + e⁻ → Ag and Cu → Cu²⁺ + 2e⁻.
- Steps 4 and 5: E°reaction = +0.80 − (+0.34) = +0.46 V. It is positive, so Cu + 2Ag⁺ → Cu²⁺ + 2Ag is spontaneous.
Try it
Use the method on Zn(s) and Cu²⁺(aq) with E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V and E°(Zn²⁺/Zn) = −0.76 V. Is the reaction spontaneous?
- Cu²⁺ is the oxidizing agent. Zn is the reducing agent. Cu²⁺ is above Zn in the table.
- E°reaction = +0.34 − (−0.76) = +1.10 V.
- It is positive, so Zn + Cu²⁺ → Zn²⁺ + Cu is spontaneous.
Slide 8 of 11 · Select partners from a mixture before calculating
Key ideas
First list what is in the beaker. Then pick the strongest oxidizing agent and the strongest reducing agent only from that list.
Ag⁺ has the higher E° (+0.80 V against +0.34 V), so it is the stronger oxidizing agent. Zn²⁺ has the lowest E°, so Zn is the stronger reducing agent.
Zn + 2Ag⁺ → Zn²⁺ + 2Ag. E°reaction = +0.80 − (−0.76) = +1.56 V. Subtracting a negative is the same as adding.
Cu and Cu²⁺ are in the mixture but not in the net equation. We do not force every substance into the equation.
Example
Given a standard mixture of Zn(s), Cu(s), Ag⁺(aq) and Cu²⁺(aq), with E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V, E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V and E°(Zn²⁺/Zn) = −0.76 V. Select the strongest reducing agent and oxidizing agent, write the net ionic equation and find E°reaction.
- Oxidizing agents present: Ag⁺ (+0.80 V) and Cu²⁺ (+0.34 V). The higher E° is Ag⁺, the strongest oxidizing agent.
- Reducing agents present: Zn and Cu. Zn²⁺/Zn has the lower E° (−0.76 V), so Zn is the strongest reducing agent.
- Zn → Zn²⁺ + 2e⁻ and 2Ag⁺ + 2e⁻ → 2Ag give Zn + 2Ag⁺ → Zn²⁺ + 2Ag.
- E°reaction = +0.80 − (−0.76) = +1.56 V, so it is spontaneous.
- Check: charge +2 = +2; Zn 1 and Ag 2 on each side.
Try it
Given a standard mixture of Fe(s), Cu(s), Ag⁺(aq) and Cu²⁺(aq), with E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V, E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V and E°(Fe²⁺/Fe) = −0.45 V. Select the strongest reducing agent and oxidizing agent, write the net ionic equation and find E°reaction.
- Oxidizing agents present: Ag⁺ (+0.80 V) and Cu²⁺ (+0.34 V). Ag⁺ has the higher E°, so it is the strongest oxidizing agent.
- Reducing agents present: Fe and Cu. Fe²⁺/Fe has the lower E° (−0.45 V), so Fe is the strongest reducing agent.
- Fe → Fe²⁺ + 2e⁻ and 2Ag⁺ + 2e⁻ → 2Ag give Fe + 2Ag⁺ → Fe²⁺ + 2Ag.
- E°reaction = +0.80 − (−0.45) = +1.25 V, so it is spontaneous.
- Check: charge +2 = +2; Fe 1 and Ag 2 on each side.
Slide 9 of 11 · Your turn: copper with zinc ions
Key ideas
Write the roles for the direction as written. Cu is the reducing agent and Zn²⁺ is the oxidizing agent.
E°reaction = E°(oxidizing agent) − E°(reducing agent) = −0.76 − (+0.34) = −1.10 V.
A negative value means the written direction is not spontaneous. The reverse, Zn with Cu²⁺, gives +1.10 V and is spontaneous.
In the table, Zn²⁺ is below Cu, so nothing happens. A copper container can safely hold a Zn²⁺ solution.
Example
Given Cu(s) and Zn²⁺(aq), with E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V and E°(Zn²⁺/Zn) = −0.76 V. Is Cu + Zn²⁺ → Cu²⁺ + Zn spontaneous under standard conditions? Justify with the numbers.
- As written, Cu is the reducing agent and Zn²⁺ is the oxidizing agent.
- E°reaction = E°(oxidizing agent) − E°(reducing agent) = −0.76 − (+0.34) = −1.10 V.
- The value is negative, so the reaction is not spontaneous as written.
- The reverse, Zn with Cu²⁺, gives +1.10 V and is spontaneous.
Try it
Given Cu(s) and Fe²⁺(aq), with E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V and E°(Fe²⁺/Fe) = −0.45 V. Is Cu + Fe²⁺ → Cu²⁺ + Fe spontaneous under standard conditions? Justify with the numbers.
- As written, Cu is the reducing agent and Fe²⁺ is the oxidizing agent.
- E°reaction = −0.45 − (+0.34) = −0.79 V.
- The value is negative, so the reaction is not spontaneous as written.
Slide 10 of 11 · Plan a virtual metal–ion investigation
Key ideas
A fair test changes one factor at a time. Compare different metals in the same ion solution.
Keep equal: clean strips of equal area, concentration, time and temperature. Add a control, such as Cu in Cu²⁺.
Record the deposit, metal loss and solution appearance. Also record no change, because it is a result.
Before each run make a prediction with a reason. The simulation is a fixed model, not real data. Running it again adds no new evidence.
Example
Question: which of Zn, Cu and Ag is the strongest reducing agent? Plan a fair investigation. State the factor you change, three factors you keep the same and what you record.
- Change: the identity of the metal (Zn, Cu, Ag).
- Keep the same: the ion solution and concentration, clean strips of equal area, time and temperature.
- Control: the same metal and ion, such as Cu in Cu²⁺.
- Record: deposit, metal loss, solution appearance and any no-change results.
Try it
A student puts Zn in Cu²⁺ for 5 s and Ag in Zn²⁺ for 60 s. Why is this not a fair comparison, and how can it be fixed?
- The metal, the solution and the time all differ, so any difference cannot be blamed on one factor.
- Fix: put each metal in the same ion solution for the same time.
Slide 11 of 11 · Make an evidence-based claim
Key ideas
A good conclusion has a claim, then evidence, then an electron explanation.
As reducing agents, Zn > Cu > Ag. The ions rank Ag⁺ > Cu²⁺ > Zn²⁺ as oxidizing agents.
Zn reacts with Cu²⁺, so Zn gives electrons to Cu²⁺. Cu reacts with Ag⁺, so Cu is a stronger reducing agent than Ag.
No visible change does not prove a reaction is impossible. A limitation can be an oxide coating or a reaction too slow to see.
Example
Given these example results: Zn reacts with Cu²⁺ and Ag⁺; Cu reacts with Ag⁺; Ag reacts with neither Zn²⁺ nor Cu²⁺. State a ranking, cite two comparisons and name one limitation.
- Claim: as reducing agents, Zn > Cu > Ag.
- Evidence 1: Zn reacts with Cu²⁺, so Zn gave electrons to Cu²⁺ and is the stronger reducing agent.
- Evidence 2: Cu reacts with Ag⁺, so Cu is a stronger reducing agent than Ag. This extends the order.
- Limitation: an oxide coating or a slow reaction could hide a change, so no visible change does not prove impossibility.
Try it
Given these example results: Zn reacts with Fe²⁺; Fe reacts with Cu²⁺; Cu reacts with neither Fe²⁺ nor Zn²⁺. State a ranking, cite two comparisons and name one limitation.
- Claim: as reducing agents, Zn > Fe > Cu.
- Evidence 1: Zn reacts with Fe²⁺, so Zn gave electrons to Fe²⁺ and is a stronger reducing agent than Fe.
- Evidence 2: Fe reacts with Cu²⁺, so Fe is a stronger reducing agent than Cu.
- Limitation: no visible change for Cu does not prove it is impossible, because a slow reaction could be missed.
Practice 1
Given Zn(s), Ag⁺(aq), E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V and E°(Zn²⁺/Zn) = −0.76 V from the Alberta table. Predict which way the reaction goes under standard conditions. Write the balanced equation.
Use Method: how to predict a redox reaction with the table. Ag⁺ is the oxidizing agent and Zn is the reducing agent. Ag⁺ is above Zn in the table. +0.80 − (−0.76) = +1.56 V, so Zn + 2Ag⁺ → Zn²⁺ + 2Ag is spontaneous. The charge is +2 on each side and the atoms match.
Practice 2
Given Ag(s), Cu²⁺(aq), E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V and E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V from the Alberta table, decide whether 2Ag + Cu²⁺ → 2Ag⁺ + Cu is spontaneous under standard conditions. Show the E° values.
Use Method: how to predict a redox reaction with the table. Cu²⁺ would be the oxidizing agent and Ag the reducing agent. Cu²⁺ is below Ag in the table. +0.34 − (+0.80) = −0.46 V. The reaction as written is not spontaneous under standard conditions.
Practice 3
Given test results for three unknown metals: metal P reacts with Q²⁺ and gets a coating of Q. Metal Q reacts with R²⁺ and gets a coating of R. Each metal forms one ion: P²⁺, Q²⁺ or R²⁺. The conditions are the same in each test. Rank the reducing agents and the oxidizing agents.
Reducing agents: P > Q > R. Oxidizing agents: R²⁺ > Q²⁺ > P²⁺. P gives electrons more easily than Q, and Q more easily than R. The matching ions rank the other way.
Practice 4
A trial shows no visible deposit after ten seconds. Does this alone prove that the reaction cannot happen under standard conditions? Explain.
No. A slow reaction, a coating on the metal or a change too faint to see can hide it. Check the conditions, the metal surface and the time, and compare with the table prediction. No change seen is weak evidence.
Practice 5
Plan a fair test to compare Zn(s) and Ag(s) as reducing agents with Cu²⁺. Name the one thing you change, two things you keep the same and one thing you record.
Change the metal. Keep the Cu²⁺ concentration, the volume of solution, the temperature, the size of the clean metal strip and the time the same. Record any coating and any loss of metal. The blue colour of Cu²⁺ may fade. The table predicts that Zn reacts and Ag does not.
Practice 6
Given the table pair Cu²⁺ + 2e⁻ → Cu with E° = +0.34 V, a student triples it and reports +1.02 V. Explain the error.
Triple the coefficients to match the electrons, but leave E° at +0.34 V. A volt is energy for each unit of charge. Tripling both the energy and the charge does not change it.
Practice 7
Given the Data Booklet table values E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V, E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V and E°(Zn²⁺/Zn) = −0.76 V. A solution that contains Cu²⁺(aq) must be stored. Can it be kept in a zinc container? Can it be kept in a silver container? Explain with the table.
Use Method: how to predict a redox reaction with the table. Cu²⁺ is the oxidizing agent. The metal of the container is the reducing agent. Zinc: Cu²⁺ is above Zn in the table. E°reaction = +0.34 − (−0.76) = +1.10 V. It is spontaneous, so the zinc container reacts and is eaten away. Do not use zinc. Silver: Cu²⁺ is below Ag in the table. E°reaction = +0.34 − (+0.80) = −0.46 V. It is not spontaneous, so the silver container is safe.
Practice 8
Challenge: Given a solution that contains both Ag⁺(aq) and Cu²⁺(aq). A strip of nickel is placed in it. Data Booklet table values: E°(Ag⁺/Ag) = +0.80 V, E°(Cu²⁺/Cu) = +0.34 V and E°(Ni²⁺/Ni) = −0.26 V. Which ion reacts first? Write the balanced equation and find E°reaction in volts.
List what is in the beaker: Ag⁺, Cu²⁺ and Ni(s). The strongest oxidizing agent is the ion with the highest table value, Ag⁺. The only reducing agent is Ni. So Ag⁺ reacts first: 2Ag⁺(aq) + Ni(s) → 2Ag(s) + Ni²⁺(aq). E°reaction = E°(oxidizing agent) − E°(reducing agent) = +0.80 − (−0.26) = +1.06 V. It is positive, so the reaction is spontaneous. The value is not multiplied by 2.
The PDF key follows the slides, with worked answers.