B9 · Worked examples

These questions are about poles, compasses, field lines, the Earth as a magnet and domains. Most need no calculation. They need the right rule and a clear reason.

Open the B9 lesson · B9 notes and practice

Method slides in this lesson: “Method: how to draw the field lines of a bar magnet”. Find them in the lesson slides, with the steps for each skill in one place.

Worked question types

Each example shows every step, why you do it, and the idea behind it.

Question type

Decide if an object is a magnet or only magnetic

Use this when: A question describes what a bar does near each end of a bar magnet. It asks which bars are magnets, which are only magnetic, and which pole is on a certain end.

Example. Three small bars are brought close to both ends of a bar magnet, with the same end of each bar used at both ends of the magnet. Bar X is attracted to both the north end and the south end. Bar Y is attracted to the south end and repelled by the north end. Bar Z is not affected by either end. Which bar is a magnet? Which is only magnetic? What pole is on the end of Y nearest the north end?
  1. Look for repulsion first.

    Only two magnets can repel each other. Repulsion needs like poles on both objects.

    Y is repelled by the north end, so Y is a magnet

  2. Look at the bars that are only attracted.

    A magnet can attract a magnet or a magnetic material such as iron. The material has no poles of its own. A magnet makes a magnetic material act like a magnet for a short time (the section on domains shows how), so either end of the bar magnet attracts it.

    X is attracted to both ends, so X is magnetic but not a magnet

  3. Check the bar with no effect.

    A bar that is not attracted to either end is not a magnetic material. Plastic and wood are examples.

    Z is not magnetic

  4. Find the pole on Y.

    Like poles repel. Y is repelled by the north end, so the end of Y nearest it must be the same kind of pole.

    the end of Y nearest the north end is a north pole

Why this works. A magnet has poles, so it can repel. A magnetic material has no poles of its own, so it is only attracted. Attraction alone cannot prove that a bar is a magnet.

Check your answer. Ask: "Did any bar get pushed away?" Only a bar that was pushed away can be called a magnet.

Common mistake. Using attraction as proof of a magnet. An iron nail is attracted to both ends and is not a magnet.

Answer: Y is the magnet. X is only magnetic. Z is not magnetic. The end of Y nearest the north end is a north pole.

Question type

Count the poles when a magnet is cut

Use this when: A magnet is cut in half, or into several pieces, and the question asks how many pieces, how many poles, or whether a single pole can be made.

Example. A bar magnet is cut in half. Each half is then cut in half again. How many pieces are there? How many north poles and how many south poles are there in all? Can you make a piece with only a north pole?
  1. Count the pieces.

    One cut makes two pieces. Cutting every piece in half again doubles the number again.

    2 × 2 = 4 pieces

  2. Give each piece its poles.

    Poles always come in pairs. Every piece of a magnet has a north pole and a south pole.

    4 pieces × 2 poles = 8 poles

  3. Split the poles into kinds.

    Each piece has one north pole and one south pole.

    north poles: 4 south poles: 4

  4. Answer the last part.

    A single pole, called a monopole, has never been found. Cutting never separates the poles.

    no, every piece has both poles

Why this works. Cutting a magnet does not split north from south. Each piece is a smaller magnet with both poles. This is why a single pole can never be isolated.

Check your answer. The number of north poles must equal the number of south poles. Here both are the same.

Common mistake. Thinking each half has only one pole. Each half has a north pole and a south pole.

Answer: 4 pieces, 4 north poles and 4 south poles. No, you cannot make a piece with only one pole.

Question type

Predict the direction a compass points near a bar magnet

Use this when: A question gives a bar magnet and compasses at different places. It asks which way the north pole of each compass points: left, right, up or down.

Method slide in the lesson: “Method: how to draw the field lines of a bar magnet”. Its numbered steps give the order; the steps below add the reason for each.

Example. A bar magnet has its north pole on the left and its south pole on the right. Compass P is above the middle of the magnet. Compass Q is below the middle. Compass R is level with the magnet, beside the left end. Compass T is level with the magnet, beside the right end. Which way does the north pole of each compass point?
  1. Recall the compass rule.

    The north pole of a compass is pulled toward a south pole and pushed away from a north pole. The field direction is the way the north pole points.

    pull toward S, push away from N

  2. Do P and Q.

    Above and below the middle, the two poles are the same distance away. The pull toward the south pole on the right and the push away from the north pole on the left both point right.

    P: right Q: right

  3. Do R.

    R is next to the north pole on the left. That pole is the nearer one. The compass is pushed away from it, so it is pushed to the left.

    R: left

  4. Do T.

    T is next to the south pole on the right. The compass is pulled toward that nearer pole. The pole is on the left of T, so the pull is to the left.

    T: left

  5. Check with field lines.

    Outside a magnet the field lines leave the north pole and enter the south pole. At each place, the compass points along the line.

    above and below: left to right; at the ends the lines point away from N and toward S

Why this works. A compass is a tiny magnet. Its north pole follows the field, so it points the way a north pole would be pushed. Field lines show those directions.

Check your answer. Check that the compasses beside the two ends do not point opposite ways. Here both point left, along the field line.

Common mistake. Using the south end of the compass. The field points the way the north end of the compass points.

Answer: P: right. Q: right. R: left. T: left.

Question type

Read field lines: direction, strength and uniform fields

Use this when: Field lines are described. The question asks for the direction at a point, where the field is strongest, or what a region of straight lines tells you.

Method slide in the lesson: “Method: how to draw the field lines of a bar magnet”. Its numbered steps give the order; the steps below add the reason for each.

Example. Field lines outside a bar magnet leave the left end and enter the right end. The lines are crowded together near both ends and are spread apart far away. Between the opposite poles of a horseshoe magnet the lines are straight, parallel and evenly spaced. Which end is the north pole? Where is the field strongest? What does the straight region tell you? Which way does a compass point on a line?
  1. Find the north pole.

    Field lines leave the north pole and enter the south pole.

    the left end is the north pole

  2. Find where the field is strongest.

    The closer together the lines are, the stronger the field is. The lines are closest near the poles.

    strongest near the two ends

  3. Read the straight region.

    Lines that are straight, parallel and evenly spaced mean the field has the same size and direction at every point. It is a uniform field.

    uniform, like the electric field between plates

  4. Find the compass direction.

    A compass lines up along the line at that point. Its north pole points the way the arrow on the line points.

    along the line, in the direction of the arrow

Why this works. Direction comes from the arrows. Strength comes from how close the lines are. Where the lines do not change, the field does not change.

Check your answer. Field lines never cross, because the field has only one direction at each point.

Common mistake. Reading strength from the length of a line. Strength comes from how close the lines are to each other.

Answer: The left end is north. The field is strongest near the poles. The straight region is a uniform field. A compass points along the line, the way the arrow points.

Question type

Use a compass to find the poles of the Earth or a model Earth

Use this when: A compass points toward the top of a globe or map, and the question asks which kind of pole is there. It may then turn the model over and ask what the compass does.

Example. A student hides a bar magnet in a plastic ball and uses it as a model Earth. A compass at the equator of the ball points toward the label "north" at the top. Which pole of the magnet is at the top? Which way does the field point at the compass? The ball is then turned upside down while the compass stays where it is in the room. Which way does the north pole of the compass point now? What kind of magnetic pole does the real Earth have near the Arctic?
  1. Use the compass rule.

    The north pole of a compass is attracted only to a south pole. It points toward the top, so there must be a south pole there.

    the top end of the magnet is a south pole

  2. Give the field direction.

    The field points the way the north pole of the compass points.

    the field points toward the top, the label "north"

  3. Turn the ball over.

    The compass follows the poles of the magnet, not the labels on the ball. The south pole is now at the bottom.

    the north pole of the compass now points down

  4. Apply it to the Earth.

    A compass needle in Alberta points toward the Arctic. So the Earth has a magnetic south pole near the Arctic and a magnetic north pole near the Antarctic.

    south pole near geographic north

Why this works. The Earth acts like a giant bar magnet. A north pole is attracted to a south pole, so the pole we call "north" is really a magnetic south pole.

Check your answer. The compass and the pole it points toward must be opposite kinds. North points to south.

Common mistake. Saying the magnetic pole near the Arctic is a north pole. It must be a south pole to attract the north end of a compass.

Answer: The top end is a south pole. The field points toward the top. After the ball is flipped the compass points down. The Earth has a magnetic south pole near the Arctic.

Question type

Explain magnet behaviour with domains

Use this when: A question asks you to explain why a nail is attracted and then stops, why a comb is not attracted, or how to weaken a magnet. Use the word "domains".

Example. A magnet picks up an iron nail. The nail then picks up a paper clip. When the magnet is moved away, the clip falls. Use domains to explain this. Why is a plastic comb not attracted? Give two ways to weaken a permanent magnet.
  1. Say what domains are.

    A magnetic material is made of tiny magnetic regions called domains. Each domain is a tiny magnet with a north end and a south end. A domain that can turn is called free.

    domains = tiny magnets inside the material

  2. Explain the nail near the magnet.

    The domains in the nail are random but free to turn. The field of the magnet turns them so they line up. The nail then has a north end and a south end, so it attracts the clip.

    domains line up, so the nail has poles

  3. Explain the nail after the magnet leaves.

    The atoms are always jiggling a little, which is called jostling. The jostling turns the domains back to random directions. Their effects cancel. The nail has no poles, so the clip falls.

    domains become random, so no poles

  4. Explain the comb.

    Plastic has no domains that a magnet can line up, so the comb gets no poles and is not attracted.

    nothing to line up, so not attracted

  5. Give two ways to weaken a magnet.

    Heat and hard knocks make the atoms jiggle more, which knocks domains out of line. Anything that does this weakens a permanent magnet.

    heat it, or drop or hit it

Why this works. A magnet has domains that are lined up and stay lined up. A magnetic material has free domains that line up near a magnet. Plastic has nothing that a magnet can line up.

Check your answer. An explanation needs a cause and an effect joined by "because". Each step above does this.

Common mistake. Saying the nail was a magnet all along. Its domains were random until the magnet turned them.

Answer: The magnet lined up the domains in the nail, so it had poles and attracted the clip. After the magnet left, the domains went random, so the clip fell. Plastic has nothing a magnet can line up. Heat the magnet or hit it.

Diploma-style questions

Try each question first. Then open the worked solution.

Multiple choice · outcome 30-B3.1k
Object R is repelled by the south pole of a bar magnet. Which statement must be true?
  1. A. R is a magnet, and the end of R nearest the bar magnet is a south pole.
  2. B. R is a magnet, and the end of R nearest the bar magnet is a north pole.
  3. C. R is only magnetic, and the end of R nearest the bar magnet is a south pole.
  4. D. R could be a magnet or a magnetic material, so its pole cannot be found.
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
  1. Use the repulsion test.

    Only two magnets can repel each other. So R must be a magnet, not just a magnetic material.

    R is a magnet

  2. Find the pole on R.

    Like poles repel. The end of R nearest the south pole must also be a south pole.

    that end of R is a south pole

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A. Correct. Repulsion needs two magnets. Like poles repel, so the end of R is a south pole.
  • B. A north pole would be attracted to the south pole, not repelled.
  • C. A magnetic material has no poles. It can only be attracted, never repelled.
  • D. Repulsion can only happen between two magnets, so it does show that R is a magnet.

Answer: A

Multiple choice · outcome 30-B3.2k
A compass at the equator of a model Earth points toward the bottom of the page. The model is a bar magnet inside a ball. Which statement describes the magnet?
  1. A. The top end is a south pole, because the compass points away from it.
  2. B. The bottom end is a north pole, because the compass points toward it.
  3. C. The top end is a north pole, because the compass points toward the south pole at the bottom.
  4. D. Both ends are south poles, because the compass points to one of them.
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
  1. Use the compass rule.

    The north pole of a compass is attracted to a south pole. It points toward the bottom, so the bottom end of the magnet is a south pole.

    bottom = south pole

  2. Find the other end.

    A magnet has one pole at each end. The top end must be a north pole.

    top = north pole

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A. A compass is attracted to a south pole, so it points toward one. It does not point away from a south pole.
  • B. The north pole of a compass is not attracted to a north pole. It would be pushed away.
  • C. Correct. North attracts south. The south pole is at the bottom, so the north pole is at the top.
  • D. A magnet always has one north pole and one south pole.

Answer: C

Numerical response · outcome 30-B3.1k
A bar magnet is cut into 6 pieces. How many magnetic poles are there in all? Record your answer as a whole number. Enter its digits from left to right, so two digits use the first two boxes.
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
  1. Give every piece two poles.

    Poles come in pairs. Every piece has a north pole and a south pole.

    2 poles per piece

  2. Multiply.

    Poles = pieces × 2.

    6 × 2 = 12

  3. Enter the digits.

    The answer has two digits: 1 and 2.

    record 1 2

Answer: 12 poles. Record 1 2.