B5 · Worked examples

These questions give you a graph or its data. You find a slope, say what it means, predict a value, or find a constant such as Coulomb’s constant.

Open the B5 lesson · B5 notes and practice

Method slides in this lesson: “Method: how to get slope and constants from a graph” · “Method: how to straighten a curve”. Find them in the lesson slides, with the steps for each skill in one place.

Worked question types

Each example shows every step, why you do it, and the idea behind it.

Question type

Name the variables and choose the axes

Use this when: A student describes an experiment and the question asks which variable is changed, which is measured, which is kept the same, and what goes on each axis.

Example. A student pulls one spring to chosen stretches, set on a ruler, and reads the force on a force meter each time. Which quantity is manipulated? Which is responding? What is held fixed? Which goes on the horizontal axis?
  1. Find what the student chose to change.

    The manipulated variable is the one the student sets on purpose.

    the stretch of the spring

  2. Find what the student measured.

    The responding variable is the one that changes because of the manipulated variable.

    the force on the meter

  3. Find what must stay the same.

    Anything that could change the result must be held fixed, or it spoils the test.

    the same spring

  4. Place the variables on the axes.

    The manipulated variable goes on the horizontal axis. The responding variable goes on the vertical axis.

    horizontal: stretch vertical: force

  5. Write the answer in one line.

    Say all four parts.

    manipulated: stretch; responding: force; fixed: the spring; horizontal axis: stretch

Why this works. A fair test changes one thing and measures one thing. Everything else is held fixed, so it cannot explain the pattern. The graph then shows how the responding variable depends on the manipulated one.

Check your answer. You can check by asking: "Which one did the student choose, and which one did the student read from an instrument?"

Common mistake. Putting the measured quantity (the force) on the horizontal axis. The manipulated variable (the stretch) goes there.

Answer: Manipulated: stretch. Responding: force. Fixed: the same spring. Horizontal axis: stretch.

Question type

Find the slope of a line, with its unit

Use this when: The question gives two points on a line of best fit, or lets you read two points from the graph, and asks for the slope.

Method slide in the lesson: “Method: how to get slope and constants from a graph”. Its numbered steps give the order; the steps below add the reason for each.

Example. A line of best fit for a spring passes through A = (2.0 × 10⁻² m, 1.20 N) and B = (8.0 × 10⁻² m, 3.00 N). Find the slope, including its unit.
  1. Choose two points far apart.

    Points that are far apart make a small reading error matter less. These two are given.

    A and B

  2. Find the rise.

    Rise is the change in the vertical quantity, here the force in N. Take the second point minus the first, B minus A.

    rise = 3.00 N − 1.20 N = 1.80 N

  3. Find the run in the same order.

    Run is the change in the horizontal quantity. Take B minus A again. Keep the power of ten.

    run = (8.0 − 2.0) × 10⁻² m = 0.060 m

  4. Divide rise by run.

    The slope is rise ÷ run.

    slope = 1.80 N ÷ 0.060 m = 30.0 N/m

  5. Check the unit.

    The unit of a slope is the vertical unit over the horizontal unit.

    N ÷ m = N/m ✓

Why this works. The slope tells you how much the vertical quantity changes for each one unit of the horizontal quantity. Here the spring force grows by 30 N for every metre of stretch.

Check your answer. A power-of-ten error is the most common mistake. If you get 300 or 0.30, check the run.

Common mistake. Using the data points as if they were on the line, or taking A minus B on the top and B minus A on the bottom.

Answer: 30.0 N/m

Question type

Say what the slope and the intercept mean

Use this when: The question gives the equation of a line of best fit and the physics quantities, and asks what the slope and the vertical intercept mean.

Method slide in the lesson: “Method: how to get slope and constants from a graph”. Its numbered steps give the order; the steps below add the reason for each.

Example. A cart moves along a track. The line of best fit for its position against time is position = (0.80 m/s)(time) + 0.25 m, with position in metres and time in seconds. What does the slope represent? What does the vertical intercept represent?
  1. Write the general line.

    In y = mx + b, y is the vertical quantity and x is the horizontal quantity. m is the slope. b is the vertical intercept, the value of y where x is 0.

    y = mx + b

  2. Match the quantities.

    Position is on the vertical axis, so it takes the place of y. Time is on the horizontal axis, so it takes the place of x. Here the letter x is not the position.

    y ↔ position x ↔ time

  3. Read the slope.

    The slope is 0.80, and its unit is m/s: metres of position per second. That is speed.

    slope = speed = 0.80 m/s

  4. Read the intercept.

    The intercept is the position when the time is 0. It has the unit of position.

    intercept = 0.25 m

  5. Say what it means.

    At time zero the cart is already 0.25 m from the origin. It did not start at the origin.

    starting position = 0.25 m

Why this works. A straight-line graph always follows y = mx + b. The slope has the unit of y divided by the unit of x. The intercept has the unit of y. In physics these two numbers are often a speed and a starting value.

Check your answer. Check the units. m/s is a speed. m is a position. Both make sense.

Common mistake. Saying the intercept is zero because most graphs start at the origin. This one does not.

Answer: The slope is the speed, 0.80 m/s. The intercept is the starting position, 0.25 m.

Question type

Predict a value from the whole line, intercept included

Use this when: The question gives the equation of the line and asks for a value of one variable from a value of the other. The line does not pass through the origin.

Method slide in the lesson: “Method: how to get slope and constants from a graph”. Its numbered steps give the order; the steps below add the reason for each.

Example. A spring experiment gives the line F = (30.0 N/m)x + 0.40 N. What extension does the line predict for a force of 2.20 N? What force does it predict for an extension of 4.0 cm?
  1. Write the line.

    Use the whole equation, including the 0.40 N. The equation F = kx alone would leave it out.

    F = (30.0 N/m)x + 0.40 N

  2. Put the known force in for F.

    The question gives F = 2.20 N and asks for x.

    2.20 = 30.0x + 0.40

  3. Subtract the intercept first.

    Get the term with x alone. Then divide by the slope.

    2.20 − 0.40 = 1.80 = 30.0x

  4. Divide by the slope.

    Use the unit of the slope to get metres.

    x = 1.80 N ÷ 30.0 N/m = 0.060 m

  5. Change 4.0 cm to metres for the second part.

    The line uses SI units.

    4.0 cm = 0.040 m

  6. Put the extension in for x.

    Multiply, then add the intercept.

    F = (30.0)(0.040) + 0.40. First (30.0)(0.040) = 1.20. Then F = 1.20 + 0.40 = 1.60 N

Why this works. The line is the experiment's answer, so use all of it. The intercept says the spring has 0.40 N of force even at zero extension. Predictions are reliable only inside the range of the data.

Check your answer. Put the answer back in the line. 30.0 × 0.060 + 0.40 = 2.20 N ✓.

Common mistake. Dividing 2.20 by 30.0 and skipping the intercept. That gives 0.073 m, which is wrong.

Answer: x = 0.060 m; F = 1.60 N

Question type

Find Coulomb’s constant from a field graph

Use this when: A graph of field strength E against source charge Q is a straight line at one fixed distance. You must use the slope to find k, Coulomb’s constant (not a spring constant).

Method slide in the lesson: “Method: how to get slope and constants from a graph”. Its numbered steps give the order; the steps below add the reason for each.

Example. A probe measures the field E at a fixed distance r = 0.400 m from a source. The charge Q of the source is changed. The line of best fit passes through M = (2.0 × 10⁻⁶ C, 1.1 × 10⁵ N/C) and N = (8.0 × 10⁻⁶ C, 4.4 × 10⁵ N/C). Find the experimental value of k.
  1. Match the equation to the line.

    The field of a point source is E = kQ ÷ r², where E is in N/C, Q is the source charge in C, r is the distance from the source in m and k is Coulomb’s constant. At a fixed r, this is E = (k ÷ r²)Q, which has the form y = mx.

    slope = k ÷ r²

  2. Find the rise.

    Take N minus M for the field.

    rise = (4.4 − 1.1) × 10⁵ = 3.30 × 10⁵ N/C

  3. Find the run.

    Take N minus M for the charge. The charges are already in coulombs: 1 μC = 1 × 10⁻⁶ C.

    run = (8.0 − 2.0) × 10⁻⁶ = 6.0 × 10⁻⁶ C

  4. Find the slope.

    Divide rise by run.

    slope = 3.30 × 10⁵ ÷ (6.0 × 10⁻⁶) = 5.50 × 10¹⁰ N/C²

  5. Solve for k.

    Multiply the slope by r². The distance is squared.

    k = slope × r² = (5.50 × 10¹⁰)(0.400)² = 8.80 × 10⁹ N·m²/C²

  6. Check the unit.

    (N/C²)(m²) = N·m²/C².

    ✓

  7. Compare with the data sheet.

    The accepted value is 8.99 × 10⁹. Find the percent difference.

    |8.80 × 10⁹ − 8.99 × 10⁹| ÷ (8.99 × 10⁹) = 2.1%

Why this works. The slope of the line is not k alone. It is k divided by r². The distance is held fixed, so it is a constant that you multiply back in. This is how a graph turns many measurements into one value of a constant.

Check your answer. The value should be close to 8.99 × 10⁹. A small difference is normal for a real experiment.

Common mistake. Giving the slope as the value of k. You must multiply by r².

Answer: k = 8.80 × 10⁹ N·m²/C², about 2.1% from the data-sheet value

Question type

Straighten a curve by plotting against 1/r²

Use this when: The force against distance is a curve. The question asks you to plot something else so the graph is a straight line, then use the slope.

Method slide in the lesson: “Method: how to straighten a curve”. Its numbered steps give the order; the steps below add the reason for each.

Example. Two fixed charges of 3.00 μC and 5.00 μC are placed different distances r apart. A graph of F against r is a curve. A graph of F against 1/r² is a straight line through G = (2.0 m⁻², 0.27 N) and H = (8.0 m⁻², 1.08 N). Find the experimental value of k.
  1. Say why a curve is no use.

    A curve has no single slope. Rise over run changes with every pair of points.

    F against r is a curve

  2. Write Coulomb’s law as a line.

    F = kq₁q₂ × (1 ÷ r²), where q₁ and q₂ are the sizes of the two charges with no minus sign. Let y = F and x = 1/r². Then the slope is kq₁q₂.

    slope = kq₁q₂

  3. Find the slope from G and H.

    Take H minus G on both the top and the bottom. The unit is the vertical unit over the horizontal unit: N ÷ m⁻² = N·m².

    slope = (1.08 − 0.27) ÷ (8.0 − 2.0) = 0.135 N·m²

  4. Solve for k.

    Divide the slope by the product of the charges.

    k = 0.135 ÷ [(3.00 × 10⁻⁶)(5.00 × 10⁻⁶)] = 9.00 × 10⁹ N·m²/C²

  5. Check the unit.

    N·m² divided by C² is N·m²/C².

    ✓

  6. Say what you learned.

    The straight line confirms that the force is proportional to 1/r².

    F ∝ 1/r²

Why this works. To get a straight line, plot against the quantity the law depends on. Coulomb's law says F is proportional to 1/r², so plot F against 1/r². The slope then holds all the constants together.

Check your answer. The value is close to 8.99 × 10⁹, so the method and the units are right.

Common mistake. Plotting F against r² or against 1/r. Only 1/r² gives a straight line for this law.

Answer: k = 9.00 × 10⁹ N·m²/C²

Diploma-style questions

Try each question first. Then open the worked solution.

Multiple choice · outcome 30-B1.3s
The electric field E at distance r from a point source is E = kQ/r². Which graph gives a straight line, and what does its slope equal?
  1. A. E against r; the slope equals kQ
  2. B. E against r²; the slope equals kQ
  3. C. E against 1/r; the slope equals kQ
  4. D. E against 1/r²; the slope equals kQ
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
  1. Write the law as a line.

    E = kQ × (1 ÷ r²). Let y = E and x = 1/r².

    y = (kQ)x

  2. Read the slope.

    The slope is the part that multiplies x.

    slope = kQ

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A. E against r is a curve, so it has no single slope.
  • B. E gets smaller as r² gets larger, so this is also a curve.
  • C. E is proportional to 1/r², not to 1/r, so this graph is still curved.
  • D. Correct. E is proportional to 1/r², and the slope is kQ.

Answer: D

Numerical response · outcome 30-B1.4s
A probe is 0.200 m from a source. A graph of field strength E against source charge Q has a line of best fit. It passes through M = (3.0 × 10⁻⁶ C, 6.6 × 10⁵ N/C) and N = (9.0 × 10⁻⁶ C, 2.0 × 10⁶ N/C). Find the experimental value of Coulomb’s constant. Record your answer as a.bc × 10ⁿ N·m²/C². Enter the digits a, b, c, and then n.
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
  1. Find the slope.

    Rise over run, N minus M.

    slope = (2.0 × 10⁶ − 6.6 × 10⁵) ÷ (6.0 × 10⁻⁶) = 2.233 × 10¹¹ N/C². Keep the full value on your calculator.

  2. Use slope = k ÷ r².

    The slope of E against Q at a fixed r is k ÷ r².

    k = slope × r²

  3. Calculate.

    Square the distance.

    k = (2.233 × 10¹¹)(0.200)² = 8.93 × 10⁹ N·m²/C²

  4. Enter the digits.

    a, b, c are 8, 9, 3, and n is 9.

    record 8 9 3 9

Answer: 8.93 × 10⁹ N·m²/C². Record 8 9 3 9.

Multiple choice · outcome 30-B1.6k
The line of best fit for a cart’s speed v against time t is v = 2.0t + 3.0, with v in m/s and t in s. What does the number 3.0 represent?
  1. A. The acceleration of the cart in m/s²
  2. B. The time when the cart stops, in s
  3. C. The speed of the cart at t = 0, in m/s
  4. D. The distance the cart travels in the first second
Show the worked solution (try the question first)
  1. Match the line to y = mx + b.

    The 3.0 stands alone, so it is the vertical intercept b.

    b = 3.0

  2. Say what b is.

    The intercept is the value of v when t = 0. Its unit is the unit of v.

    v at t = 0

  3. Choose the meaning.

    The cart already has a speed of 3.0 m/s when the timing starts.

    initial speed = 3.0 m/s

Why each choice is right or wrong

  • A. The acceleration is the slope, 2.0 m/s², not the intercept.
  • B. The line gives a speed when t = 0. It does not give a time.
  • C. Correct. The intercept is the speed when the time is zero.
  • D. A distance would need a position graph. This graph has speed on the vertical axis.

Answer: C