A10 · Polar and non-polar molecules · Completed notes

Goals: Explain what makes a molecule polar or non-polar. Use the shape of a molecule to decide whether its bond dipoles cancel. Decide whether a molecule is polar, and give the reason.

These are the completed notes. The blanks are filled in and each question is worked.

Slide 1 of 7 · From polar bonds to polar molecules

In lesson A7, a bond could be polar. In lesson A9, a molecule got a shape. Today you put the two together and ask if a whole molecule is polar.

BrF3.04.0δ−δ+bond dipolea polar bond has a δ− end and a δ+ end

Key ideas

A polar molecule has a slightly negative side and a slightly positive side.

A non-polar molecule has no negative side and no positive side.

The bond dipole arrow points to the δ− end.

Example

What is the difference between a polar bond and a polar molecule?

  1. A polar bond has a δ− end and a δ+ end.
  2. A polar molecule has a slightly negative side and a slightly positive side.

Try it

A molecule has no negative side and no positive side. What kind of molecule is it?

  1. No side is slightly negative or slightly positive.
  2. So it is a non-polar molecule.

Slide 2 of 7 · A molecule with one bond

Start with the simplest case, a molecule with two atoms. It has only one bond, so that bond decides everything.

BrFδ+δ−BrBrBrF is a polar molecule.Nothing cancels its bond dipole.Br₂ is a non-polar molecule.It has no bond dipole.

Key ideas

A molecule with two different atoms has one polar bond.

Nothing can cancel it, so the molecule is polar.

Two atoms of the same element make a non-polar molecule.

Example

Is hydrogen chloride, HCl, a polar molecule? Say why.

  1. HCl has two different atoms, so its one bond is polar.
  2. Nothing can cancel it, so HCl is polar.

Try it

Is nitrogen gas, N₂, a polar molecule? Say why.

  1. N₂ has two atoms of the same element.
  2. Its bond is non-polar, so N₂ is non-polar.

Slide 3 of 7 · Bond dipoles that cancel

On the last slide, one polar bond made a polar molecule. With several polar bonds, the shape matters. The bonds can pull against each other.

COOcarbon dioxide, CO₂linear2 equal arrows, oppositenon-polar molecule
SOOOsulfur trioxide, SO₃trigonal planar3 equal arrows, evenly spreadnon-polar molecule
ClCClClClcarbon tetrachloride, CCl₄tetrahedral4 equal arrows, evenly spreadnon-polar molecule

Key ideas

Equal arrows that point in opposite directions cancel.

CO₂ is linear, so it is a non-polar molecule.

Linear, trigonal planar and tetrahedral shapes can cancel.

They cancel when all the outer atoms are the same.

Example

Carbon tetrafluoride, CF₄, is tetrahedral. All 4 outer atoms are fluorine. Is CF₄ polar? Say why.

  1. Each arrow points from carbon to fluorine.
  2. The 4 arrows are equal and evenly spread.
  3. They cancel, so CF₄ is non-polar.

Try it

Silicon tetrachloride, SiCl₄, is tetrahedral. All 4 outer atoms are chlorine. Is SiCl₄ polar? Say why.

  1. Each arrow points from silicon to chlorine.
  2. The 4 arrows are equal and evenly spread.
  3. They cancel, so SiCl₄ is non-polar.

Slide 4 of 7 · Bond dipoles that never cancel

On the last slide, equal arrows pulled against each other and cancelled. A lone pair on the centre atom stops that. The molecule is lopsided.

FNFFThe fluorine atoms are the δ− side.nitrogen trifluoride, NF₃trigonal pyramidalthe arrows all lean one waypolar molecule
OFFThe fluorine atoms are the δ− side.oxygen difluoride, OF₂angularthe arrows all lean one waypolar molecule

Key ideas

A lone pair on the centre atom makes the molecule lopsided.

In NF₃, the 3 arrows do not cancel.

Trigonal pyramidal and angular molecules with polar bonds are polar.

Example

Ammonia, NH₃, is trigonal pyramidal. Is it polar? Say why.

  1. Each bond between nitrogen and hydrogen is polar.
  2. The 3 arrows lean the same way, so they do not cancel.
  3. So NH₃ is polar.

Try it

Water, H₂O, is angular. Is it polar? Say why.

  1. Each bond between oxygen and hydrogen is polar.
  2. The 2 arrows are not opposite, so they do not cancel.
  3. So H₂O is polar.

Slide 5 of 7 · Different outer atoms

On slide 3, three shapes cancelled because they are symmetrical. "Symmetrical" means the same on every side. But the outer atoms must match too.

ClCClClClClCHClClCCl₄ is non-polar.Its 4 outer atoms are the same.CHCl₃ is polar.Its outer atoms differ.

Key ideas

Symmetrical means the same on every side.

CHCl₃ is tetrahedral, but its arrows are not equal.

So the arrows do not cancel, and CHCl₃ is polar.

A molecule made of only carbon and hydrogen is non-polar.

Example

Chloromethane, CH₃Cl, is tetrahedral. Is it polar? Say why.

  1. The outer atoms are 3 hydrogen and 1 chlorine.
  2. They do not match, so the arrows are not equal.
  3. They do not cancel, so CH₃Cl is polar.

Try it

Butane, C₄H₁₀, is made of only carbon and hydrogen. Is it polar? Say why.

  1. A molecule made of only carbon and hydrogen is non-polar.
  2. So butane is non-polar.

Slide 6 of 7 · Method: how to decide whether a molecule is polar

You have now judged nine molecules. Each time you did the same four things. Here they are as steps.

1Find the shape around the centre atom.2Draw a bond dipole on each polar bond.3Ask if the arrows cancel.4State polar or non-polar, with the reason.shape1arrows2cancel?3answer4Check: arrows cancel with matching outer atoms and no lone pair.Used again in: lessons A11 and A12

Key ideas

Step 1: find the shape.

Step 2: draw the bond dipole arrows.

Step 3: ask if the arrows cancel.

Step 4: write the answer: polar or non-polar.

Example

Use the four steps on phosphorus trichloride, PCl₃. It has 1 lone pair on phosphorus.

  1. Step 1: PCl₃ is trigonal pyramidal.
  2. Step 2: each arrow points from phosphorus to chlorine.
  3. Step 3: the arrows lean the same way, so they do not cancel.
  4. Step 4: PCl₃ is polar.

Try it

Use the four steps on carbon tetrabromide, CBr₄. It has no lone pairs on carbon.

  1. Step 1: CBr₄ is tetrahedral.
  2. Step 2: each arrow points from carbon to bromine.
  3. Step 3: the 4 arrows are equal and evenly spread, so they cancel.
  4. Step 4: CBr₄ is non-polar.

Slide 7 of 7 · Sort a set

Now use the four steps on six molecules. Decide each one before you look at the last column.

MoleculeShapeCancel?Molecule isSiH₄tetrahedralyesnon-polarNF₃trigonal pyramidalnopolarSiI₄tetrahedralyesnon-polarOF₂angularnopolarCH₂Cl₂tetrahedralnopolarHCNlinearnopolar

Key ideas

SiH₄ and SiI₄ are symmetrical, so they are non-polar.

NF₃ and OF₂ have lone pairs on the centre atom, so they are polar.

CH₂Cl₂ and HCN have outer atoms that differ, so they are polar.

Example

Nitrogen trichloride, NCl₃, has 3 bonds and 1 lone pair on nitrogen. Is it polar? Say why.

  1. It has 4 groups with 1 lone pair, so it is trigonal pyramidal.
  2. The arrows do not cancel, so NCl₃ is polar.

Try it

Silicon tetrafluoride, SiF₄, has 4 bonds and no lone pairs on silicon. Is it polar? Say why.

  1. It is tetrahedral, and all 4 outer atoms are the same.
  2. The arrows cancel, so SiF₄ is non-polar.