A9: Investigate and connect

Molecular shapes. Do this after the lesson. It takes about 20 minutes.

Outcomes practised: 20-A2.2s, 20-A2.4s, 20-A2.6k

You need: A molecular model kit, or modelling clay and toothpicks. With neither, use the pictures on this page.

A model shows the shape of a molecule in three dimensions. Can you build a model that matches the shape you predict?

CSS
CS₂ is linear.
COClCl
COCl₂ is trigonal planar.
ClCClClCl
CCl₄ is tetrahedral.
FNFF
NF₃ is trigonal pyramidal.
OFF
OF₂ is angular.

1. Plan

  1. Draw the electron dot diagram of each molecule: CS₂, COCl₂, CCl₄, NF₃ and OF₂.
  2. Predict. Count the groups and the lone pairs around each centre atom. Name each shape.
  3. Build each model. Use one ball for each atom and one stick for each bond.
  4. Draw each model on paper. Use a wedge and a dashed line where you need them.
  5. Compare each model with its picture on this page.

2. The results

Another student built the same five models. This table describes them. You did not build these.

Another student's models
MoleculeGroupsLone pairsWhat the student's model looks like
CS₂20S, C and S in a straight line
COCl₂30O and two Cl at the corners of a flat triangle
CCl₄40four Cl at the corners of a flat square
NF₃41three F below N, like a low tripod
OF₂42F, O and F in a straight line

3. Work with the results

  1. Which two of the student's models are wrong? Name the correct shape of each.
    Compare after your attempt

    The models of CCl₄ and OF₂ are wrong. CCl₄ is tetrahedral, not a flat square. OF₂ is angular, not a straight line.

  2. Explain what the student forgot when building OF₂.
    Compare after your attempt

    The student forgot the two lone pairs on oxygen. They are two of the four groups. They push the fluorine atoms to one side.

  3. Explain how the student should change the model of CCl₄.
    Compare after your attempt

    Move the four chlorine atoms out of the flat square. One points up and three point down, like the legs of a tripod.

  4. The model of COCl₂ uses one stick between C and O. Explain why one stick is enough to show the shape.
    Compare after your attempt

    A double bond is one group. The shape depends on the number of groups, so one stick shows it.

  5. Write a conclusion of two or three sentences. Say what a model shows that a structural formula does not.
    Compare after your attempt

    A structural formula shows which atoms are joined. A model also shows where the atoms are in three dimensions. The shape follows from the groups of electrons around the centre atom.

4. Connect

  1. Chemists who design medicines build models of molecules. Explain why a flat drawing is not enough for them.
    Compare after your attempt

    A medicine molecule must fit against another molecule in the body. Whether it fits depends on its shape in three dimensions.

  2. A model kit has grey balls and white balls of different sizes. State one way the model is not like a real molecule.
    Compare after your attempt

    Real atoms have no colour and are far too small to see. The sticks are not real objects either: a bond is a shared pair of electrons.