A4: Investigate and connect

Ionic lattices and the properties they explain. Do this after the lesson. It takes about 20 minutes.

Outcomes practised: 20-A1.1s, 20-A1.3s, 20-A1.4s

You need: Paper and a pencil.

A lab has four white solids with no labels: W, X, Y and Z. Which of the four solids are ionic compounds?

1. Plan

  1. Predict. List three properties you expect an ionic solid to have. Use lesson A4.
  2. Plan the tests. For each property, write one test you could do in a school lab.
  3. Make it fair. Write what you would keep the same for all four solids.
  4. Plan for safety. Write one hazard in your tests. Write how you would lower the risk.
  5. Draw a table for your results. Give each test its own column.

2. The results

These results are examples for this lesson. Your class did not measure them.

Example results for four white solids
SolidWhat it looks likeDissolves in water?Does the solid conduct?Does the solution conduct?Melts on a hot plate?
Whard white crystalsyesnoyesno
Xhard white crystalsyesnonoyes
Ysoft white lumpsnonono solution to testyes
Zhard white crystalsyesnoyesno

3. Work with the results

  1. Which solids are ionic compounds? Give two pieces of evidence from the table.
    Compare after your attempt

    W and Z. Their solutions conduct, so they contain ions that are free to move. They also do not melt on a hot plate.

  2. Solid X dissolves, like W and Z. Explain why X is not an ionic compound.
    Compare after your attempt

    Its solution does not conduct, so it has no ions that are free to move. It also melts on a hot plate.

  3. No solid conducts in the table. Explain why this test cannot pick out the ionic solids.
    Compare after your attempt

    The ions in an ionic solid are fixed in the lattice. They cannot move, so the solid does not conduct. The other solids have no ions.

  4. A student says that every solid that dissolves in water is ionic. Use the table to judge this claim.
    Compare after your attempt

    The claim is wrong. Solid X dissolves, but its solution does not conduct. Dissolving alone is not enough evidence.

  5. Write a conclusion of two or three sentences. Answer the question and give your evidence.
    Compare after your attempt

    W and Z are ionic compounds. Their solutions conduct electricity and the solids do not melt on a hot plate. X and Y are not ionic.

4. Connect

  1. Solid W is potassium bromide. It melts at 734 °C. Solid Z is potassium fluoride. It melts at 858 °C. Explain why Z has the higher melting point.
    Compare after your attempt

    Both have ions with charges 1+ and 1−. The fluoride ion is smaller than the bromide ion. The ions in Z are closer together, so they attract more strongly.

  2. A hair dryer falls into a bath. The bath water has dissolved salts in it. Explain why this is dangerous.
    Compare after your attempt

    Dissolved salts are ions that are free to move. The water conducts, so a current can pass through a person in the bath.